Didn't See THAT Coming | Reading Reddit Stories

- Hi, welcome to Smosh Read's Reddit Stories. I'm Shayne, and today is all about updates. Now I know people have been asking for us. to do updates on stories we've read. in previous episodes of this show. That is not this episode. We found new stories that have a lot of updates, but we will be doing that at some point. We have a whole team compiling stories from the past. and searching the internet for their updates. By team, I mean, Emily and Marcus are hard at work. and Bailey as well.

Sorry. Bailey is currently not here in this room. It's through This episode today is actually. being directed by Marcus. - Woo- - Is very. - Yeah. - Very cool. - Yeah. - So I'm gonna do this. just like Culinary Crimes. (all laughing). Have you ever read a story that was so freaking weird? (all laughing). - I think we're missing an asshole? (all laughing). - I am joined by two people who have updates for me. Trevor and Angela. - Update. We're moving.

- Yes. - Yeah. - That is actually true. - I've been having some hip pain. - Oh. - Oh, personal. - Well, that's an update. - I don't know. I was literally trying to think of things. - No, no. - No, let's get medical. - I'm doing stretches, you know? - That's good. - I think it might be a basketball thing, I don't know. - Probably, yeah. Do a lot of basketball. - Getting old. - Yeah. - And you're tall. - Yeah. - Don't say you're getting old. when you're like eight years younger. You're not allowed to do that. - Just like, don't really do that. - Don't, don't just settle down. Don't do that. Yes. So we are moving as some of you watching this,

and if you're listening, you're not seeing it. We are in a temporary studio right now. The Smosh studios are moving. to our brand new space in Oxnard. - And I'm like moving. - Oxnard. - Moving. - I'm like, let me, I think we're gonna go right back. to the same building and I think they're just like-. - We're gonna come back. - Moving. - Front desk just same person, but with a mustache. - I think it's all an elaborate pit video. Moving. - Guys, it might be a prank. - I just can't let go of Rancho Cucamonga like that. - No, I know.

- It treated us so well for so long. - I know, I'm gonna miss Rancho Cucamonga. - You outgrow Rancho. - But I hear Oxnard is gorgeous. - This is awesome. Okay. We're doing full Oxnard. - I'm committing to Oxnard. - Great. I wanted to try Ventura Beach. - Close. - Yes, It's right there. - Right there. - That's why I'm saying it's perfect. - It's, maybe we're in between Oxnard and Venture. - That's it. - Yeah. - Yeah. We're right there. We just, we have our own little lot on the beach. - Yeah, and we'll- - Dude! That's where my grandpa's carpet shop is. - Dude! - And we're right next door.

- And we're in my grandpa. We're filming from my grandfather's carpet... - Dude! - Yeah. - And to be more specific, our studio is actually. on the fifth story of a condo building. - Yeah. - So we're actually in a residential building, but our studios are right there smack in the middle. - Yeah. - It's a permit thing. We can do a lot more of that. - We're allowed. We have to do whatever we want. - We can get pretty crazy. - Yeah. This podcast really good. So we're allowed to do stuff now. - Really good podcast doing good. - Podcast, doing good. We can break laws now. - That's how it works.

- We can break zoning laws. All right, are we ready to hop into some stories? - I'm so stoked. Every single one has an update? - It'd be really funny if we did updates episode... - And there were no updates. - We get to the story and Shayne's like, next story. - Sorry. We lied. Okay, let's begin. Our first story comes from am I the asshole, posted in December of 2025. Am I the a-hole. for making my daughter's boyfriend buy a new T-shirt?

Okay. Can you please settle A mild dispute for my family. On the 23rd of December, my daughter, who's 19, her boyfriend 19, came over for dinner. We had dinner then because he's going away. with his family for Christmas. He arrived, rang the bell and I answered the door. He came in, took off his jacket and that's when I saw it. He was wearing a t-shirt that said, it's not gonna suck itself. (both laughing). (beep). I took one look at that shirt.

and asked him if he had any money. He said no and asked why. I told him that the shirt showed a marked lack of respect. for both my daughter and my wife. I pulled two twenties outta my wallet. and quietly ushered him back out the door. and towards the Walmart three miles away. and told him to buy a more respectful shirt. - With 40 bucks? - With 40 bucks to buy a more respectful shirt. and come back with it on. Mind you, this whole exchange took place between him. and I without an audience. He was gone for 15 minutes,

came back with a nice polo shirt on. We had a nice dinner together. and nothing was mentioned of the incident. The next day my daughter came to me and her mother. and told us what I did humiliated him. They aren't in breakup territory or anything. and no yelling or anything of the sort went on. My wife did tell me I could have handled it differently. So Reddit, am I wrong for handling it this way? And if so, how could I have handled it? Edit, I'm 57 and a long haul truck driver, so I've had my share of bad moments. Most of us guys here can remember stupid things that we did.

as a teen, even into our twenties. The ones that stand out for me are the ones. where someone didn't react with anger or malice. They were the ones where someone reacted. with constructive kindness. One where a quiet redemption was offered, where a mirror was quietly held up to my behavior. Those are the ones I learned from and appreciated the most. Hopefully he comes out the other side. with a new appreciation for kindness offered quietly. and without fanfare. Just my thoughts. Okay. This feels pretty clear cut for me.

I think he handled it very well. Right? The shirt, hilarious. Bad though. I do not, I don't know what that guy was thinking. Showing up to dinner with his, for his girlfriend. and her parents wearing that, bold choice. He got lucky that he showed up and it was just the dad. and the dad did that and didn't kill him. - Yeah. - You (beep).

- I think... - Don't do this now. - No, honestly, I would say if I wore the t-shirt, I would think that maybe it's let's like a funny shirt. Right? - It's very generous for him. to like- - So sorry. Do you wanna go? - Oh no, you should. - Okay. (Angela and Trevor and Shayne chattering). - Okay. Gotcha. - All right. - Got ya. - And you can do a seemingly quick cut outta that. - I knew, I knew it. This combo. - It's only if we're waiting outside for too long. - Yeah. - We get some scheming. Okay. Sorry.

This shirt's hilarious. (all laughing). - There it is! - No, like truly. - When I said okay, you guys kind of got me for a second, so when I said that shirt hilarious. and you didn't respond, I was like, oh no, is it, is this really? (all laughing). Shit. - Like it's actually not that funny. - Oh, okay, yeah, actually, sorry. No, it's guess I need to rethink that. Okay I love that he like is already defending himself. in the post. - Yeah. - This guy handled this. very well, I thought.

- And he's like, and I think I did the best job. at what I could. - I think you did a great job. - Yeah, no, I mean like for him to be like, here's $40. - Jesus. - Like I feel like there, there are people out there. that would've been like, get outta my house. I never wanna see you again. Like there are people that would flip out over that. The fact that he was like, Hey man, like here's some money. Just please go get a new shirt. - This solution isn't kicking him out. Like he's still invited, so it is like kind of a respectful way. at like laying down boundaries. - Yeah, and the boyfriend did go. and get a nice polo shirt instead of going to Walmart. and he could have gotten another disrespectful shirt.

He could have come back with the man, the legend. - If this was a Lonely Island sketch, he'd come back and it'd be like-. - Something worse. - Something worse, yeah. - We'll suck that, It was like-. (all laughing). - He comes back when he just put the shirt backward. Like, what? - And he's like drinking a beer. It's like, thanks for the 40 bucks. - Also reminder the boyfriend. and girlfriend have been dating for four months, so this is probably one of the first dinners. he's having with parents. - That's what he wore?

- That shirt and those shirts aren't like come on, he's gotta have other shirts. - Yeah. - Like it's one thing. to just not dress like, well, to see your girlfriend's parents, like you would want. to kind of dress up a little bit, but to choose that shirt. This was the 23rd of December. - Yes. - That's, it's a Christmas. - What I'm wondering is like I, the girlfriend obviously has. to have a good sense of humor, but like, I'm surprised. for her to not be like, Hey, I think that shirt's hilarious. Maybe we wear something different. But her, the fact that it, I'm trying to figure out.

like if there's an acceptable age for this. to be like, ah, let the kid wear the shirt. And I don't know that there, I don't think there is. - I think it's the first time meeting the parents. four months in this, it's like, it feels like it's on its way to be serious, but it's not just yet. It feels like it's an important meeting. Like I remember I was a little bossy. with my first boyfriend when he met my parents. 'cause I was like, do you mind if we pull over and you like, and we grab something's for you to give my mom? Like, I was a little, but I was nervous. - You wanna make a good impression. because if you make that bad first impression.

with the parents, it lingers. - Yeah. - You're like, okay, I want everything to be cool. I want my parents to like you. And I like how OP the dad was like, I did this in a respectful way, that was like showing what I needed changed. - Yeah. - He like, he didn't, he wasn't just an asshole to be an asshole. - And he's a 57-year-old long haul trucker. He's probably a bit of an intimidating figure. - Yeah. - Right. Like I'm imagining a type of guy. that's like, you don't wanna piss off. - Yeah. - So to get that response. is like you better be lucky. You better be happy that that's what you got.

- 40 bucks. - The woke thing to do would've been. for the girlfriend to wear the shirt. - That would've been pretty woke. - Yeah, it would've been woke. 'cause it's like. - I'm just saying. What if they just just switched shirts? - What? Yeah. - What's another way he could have done this? Been like, please put on one of my shirts. Like, like what do you... - And so he comes back out with a shirt. that says it's not gonna suck itself, it's just bigger. (all laughing). Just an XL of it. Verdict was not the asshole. - I agree. - Comments.

You were very classy about it. And even gave him the opportunity to get a new shirt. instead of just going home and changing. Not the asshole. 14,000 up votes. Someone said, not the asshole, I think you handled it well. He was an idiot to think that shirt would go over well. with his girlfriend's family. and is lucky you didn't give him more grief for it. Someone responded to that saying, giving him money. to get a new shirt and letting him come back shows. you were willing to give him a second chance. Plus it showed you have compassion. by pointing out the issue, but also giving him help with a solution. instead of leaving him on his own to figure it out.

I'm curious what male role models he has, if any, being a teenager, he probably doesn't realize the full implication. of how disrespectful his shirt was. I think you handled it with excellence and grace. - Yeah. - Someone said, why on earth would your wife be against this? OP said she just hated the idea of him. being put on the spot. I did point out that I could have done it. in front of everyone. Yeah, he could have, put on the spot. He was not put on the spot. - He wasn't, yeah. - He saved him. - Yeah, I fear that this couldn't have gone any better.

- No, I don't know what other solution is better than that. - Yeah I feel like the mom just didn't like. the confrontation of it all. And she's blaming the dad. because she knows him. rather than blaming the person who wore the shirt. - Someone said question. What else was on the shirt? Still in bad taste, but was there a graphic printed on it? Say of say a lollipop or something like that? Op said an arrow pointing down. No, it was-. - It's like really sweet that Reddit was like, let's think of all the options. - Yeah and then beneath the arrow it said, I mean my penis just so you know.

- And he said, dad and mom of my girlfriend, see here penis down here. - All of you suck this, yeah. I think it's, it's a huge red flag. that the boyfriend wore that like, I kind of don't care. what male role models he's has. I'm like, he knew what he was doing. It feels so disrespectful and even worse now is that. after the dad did that, the boyfriend then made a big thing about it. to the girlfriend. and is making her feel bad about it and putting it on her.

- That is honestly a bigger red flag than the shirt. - Exactly. - Yeah. - Being like, oh, something I did made you feel uncomfortable. I'm gonna be mad at you for feeling that way. - Yeah, yeah, yeah, I don't like this guy. - No. - So we have an update. - Okay. - So where do we think, I don't know where this could possibly go. Is the boyfriend worse. or do we find out that how the dad handled it, is he lying about how he handled it? - Mm. - But I don't think, I don't-. - Reddit has burned you, yeah. - Yeah I don't think, I'm not buying unreliable narrator. from this guy. - No, I don't think so either. - I'm buying, there's smoke where there's fire.

This guy isn't that great of a guy. to his girlfriend and they're gonna break up. - Hmm yeah. That shirt kind of shows his values. - Yeah. - Here's what I'm thinking. and I know this is probably crazy. but I'm just gonna throw it out there. The boyfriend sneaks into the dad's closet. and finds the same exact shirt. and confronts him about being a hypocrite. - That would be the most epic version of this. That would be pretty incredible. I think maybe could even be a movie. - Yeah. Honestly. Kind of like a morality tale. - Yeah. Okay. - Thematic.

- Update the next day. - Oh, fun. - After reading these comments. and listening to everyone's point of view, I sat my daughter down this morning. and asked what her boyfriend actually said to her. This changes my opinion of him. Apparently he'd not told my daughter. what the phrase was on the shirt, but did tell her accurately what I said to him. and asked him to do. He didn't use the word humiliated. That was my daughter's interpretation. Her rush to defend him came from our examples. Apparently she's taken note. of the times I've defended my wife and vice versa.

She also took note. of our disagreements in private after the fact. She's going to talk to him when he gets back tomorrow. to follow up on why he thought the shirt was appropriate. for the family setting. I'll update again after the conversation. Okay. So he told his girlfriend, your dad made me change my shirt. It's like, what was on the shirt? It was just a normal shirt or whatever. Like he didn't tell her. Well I was wearing the, it's not gonna suck itself shirt. - I was wearing the shirt you hate. - The shirt that demeans you. - Well I was wearing the shirt you told me not to wear when. - Yeah yeah, It's not a big deal.

Okay. - Okay. I'm already like okay, not really communicating. - All right, so the boyfriend sucks more. - Yeah. - Yeah. Not looking good for him. - No, I think it's gonna get worse. Update number two comes hours later. - Okay. - Oh hell yeah. - Great. - Update number two. My daughter called him about an hour ago. and this'll be informative. She asked him why he'd not told her. what the shirt said when he talked to her. His reply was telling because it was embarrassing. Then she went on to ask him why he wore it originally.

and he admitted that the shirt had been a gift. from his older brother who's 21. And that the older brother had dared him. to called him chicken when he objected, et cetera. Dumb sibling crap, apparently. She went on to tell him. that none of what he'd done was cool. and that she really liked him. and that he'd always been kind to her. She said she wasn't breaking up with him, but that these steps needed to be done. First he needed to explain. to his parents the entire situation. Second, he needed to show up in person to our home. and bring the money for the shirt.

and as she put it, put in a whole ass kissing session. that included the explanation of the dare, et cetera. She said that if this was handled well, they could talk about moving forward. and what that looked like. After the phone call, she talked to her mom and I. and admitted that she forgot her worth. She said that as long as she'd been alive, I had never gone out of my way to embarrass her mom. and that I'd always been respectful. and not let anyone be disrespectful to her mom. Made me feel really good. So she wasn't going to settle for less good for her. I'll update after this visit later tomorrow afternoon. Okay.

So the boyfriend's now saying, well my older brother dared me. He called me chicken and that's very powerful. - And at the end of the day, what can we say? Huh? - That's basically a spell. - Honestly though. Like I really, I was really, I've been this whole time, I'm like, what could compel a person, a 19-year-old person to wear this shirt? And that's just about the most believable thing. - Enter evil, ugly, older brother. - 19. - You should wear it dude. You should (beep) wear it. - You chicken?

- Come on. - (beep) P word. I'm not gonna say it. - We asked earlier what male role models does he have. and it found, we found out. he has a brother who's two years older than him, and that's not good. - And that ain't good-. - I'd consider myself-. - Two years older than you. Rough. - Yeah, and being called a chicken, death. - Yeah. - Yeah. Death. - I'd consider myself like, I think I was, you know, relatively like normal amount of dumb for a 19-year-old. I just, I don't think anybody could ever, no matter what you said to me, convince me to do something, I'd be like, you're the dumbest person alive. I'm not gonna do that.

- That, maybe though he was like really wanted. his older brother's approval. - Yeah. - And his older brother. was like, it's chill dude. Just wear it, It's funny. And he like... - Why wouldn't he just wear it and then go. and change it on his way? I mean he didn't have a back up shirt? - He would be a chicken. So. - Because he'd be a chicken bro. - Because ultimately that would make him a bigger chicken. - Not understand. He would be a chicken. - He would be like he would like literally become a chicken. - And his brother will know. - His brother's just in the bushes watching him walk. up to the house just like you... - Call his spell. - He like secretly changes the shirt. for the dinner and comes back home,

but he puts on the the it's not gonna suck itself. And he comes back in and his brother's like, where are you going? Smells like chicken. - Or he wakes up the next morning. He's like-. - He changed that shirt, didn't you? - He wakes up the next morning we find out his brother. is like a witch. And then he wakes up and he like feels feathers on him. and he is like, oh my god. - Oh no. - I'm a chicken! - Oh no. - Oh my God. - But honestly, in all sincerity, your sibling's opinion of you.

and your siblings calling you not cool when you're young is. like really sad. - It's death. - And you will do anything and that. And I feel bad for him because that sucks. That was bad advice. - My brothers were luckily so much older than me. that they didn't do anything of that level. But they did have that power over me. when I was a little kid. I would've done anything. But you have a sibling. who's about that age difference, right? - Yeah. He's the two and three, three years younger than me. - That's yeah, it's powerful, It's a powerful like...

I mean he's siblings that close in age, but you were older than him. - Yeah, and he still, if he says anything I do is not cool, I'm like... - It's rough. - I kept saying tats instead of tattoo. when we were both getting tattoos. and he texted me with the artist, I'm getting tattooed. We both getting sibling tattoos. and I kept going, so what's like the longest tat. you've ever given? Or what's, and I kept saying tat, and I was like, that's a cool tat. And my brother texted me in all caps, please stop saying tat it's really uncool. And he was right next to me and the artist. - No. - Oh.

- That'd be devastating. - But it is like really uncool. to say tat is what I learned. - I don't think it's that bad. - Like that's a nice tat. - Yeah, you're fine. - I know. But you know siblings, it just cuts, It cuts deep. - Oh yeah. - 'cause it just right goes back to when you were like a kid. and you had no fricking like... - A beast like me doesn't really care. - Yeah. - I've talked about my brother though. - Beast like me. - A beast like me doesn't care. - A beast like me. Alright, update number three. - Well - The next day. It's December 28th, 2025. This will make those of you following this saga laugh.

I received a call this evening from Mr. Boyfriend's parents. Firstly, they're mortified and extremely apologetic. Secondly, and the best part of this update, I have their permission to squeal, is that his parents are on Reddit. and commented on my post in support of the way. I handled the situation. They told me that they love my daughter. and that we'd raised her right. and had not raised their sons to show. this level of disrespect for anyone, let alone his girlfriend. Apparently boyfriend was following up. on one of my daughter's conditions. and went to talk to his parents. As the story unfolded, his mom reached for her phone,

opened Reddit and yelled, "Is this about (beep) you?". To quote his dad-. - Oh my God. - As the son read the first half paragraph, he died a little inside. So anyways, they are going to come. to dinner tomorrow evening with boyfriend. More updates tomorrow night. Aw dude, your boy, your dad, your parents are redditors, dude. - This is crazy. - But also they're going to dinner. They can do something really funny. - Oh!

- They could be extremely funny. Is this play about us? That's what that is. Is this about you? - Dude, you know, honestly, that's something. that I'd never considered before is the people. inside of the Reddit story not being aware. that they're in a Reddit story. Like the fact of him seeing like, oh my God, there's this Reddit thread about me in real time. That's crazy. - If I'm that mother, I'm losing it. I'm going, this is, where's the shirt? Oh my God. - What if he showed up to the dinner wearing a shirt.

that says it sucks itself. (all laughing). - This situation sucks. - Don't worry itself. - I go, fine. I'll suck it myself. - Suck it myself. A shirt that says, "This is such a Reddit story.". - Merch? - My life. - My life is a Reddit story, bro. - My life is a Reddit story, bro. Suck it. (all laughing). Update number four. Dinner was very pleasant. Let me say that his parents are great. Boyfriend showed up with red roses for my daughter. and yellow roses for my wife.

He offered what I thought was a very sincere apology. and a card with the entire $40 in it, even though he'd given me the change. and receipt on the original night. I cooked tonight to give my wife a break. I made an Indian dish called butter chicken. with basmati rice. Neither had eaten curry before, but loved it. Woo-hoo. What am I reading? - I made an Indian dish. - What am I reading? - This is into David Copperfield. - What am I reading? - After that we traveled out into the country. Years later my daughter graduated.

As it turns out, his older brother is the family athlete. JV soccer, varsity soccer, and a sports scholarship. - You don't say. - The quintessential jock. Little brother is the exact opposite, artistic. He's got real talent, sensitive, quiet. Felt like he never measured up to his big brother. and works to gain his big brother's respect. Brother takes full example of this. and exploits his little brother for shits and giggles. Near the end of dinner, my daughter says, "I think I'll keep him around for a little longer. You guys okay with that?". We are good with that for now. His mom is the boss though for thinking outside the box.

As punishment to the older brother, mom went into his clothing drawers and closet, took every shirt off of him. and bought him eight very bright pink t-shirts. that he'll wear until he realizes just how damaging. exploiting someone, anyone is. His access to cash is also cut off. until said lesson is learned. Anyway, a successful night with new friends was enjoyed. Hope this was the update you hoped for. - Oh these are... - They came with butter chicken. and all that fun stuff. - I'm so-. - They disowned their other son. - These are- - And he's gotta wear pink.

- These are grown ass kids, man. This is a 19 and a 21-year-old, like, come on. - I guess, I don't know like. what high schoolers go through now. I feel like wearing a pink t-shirt does not hit like it did. back in like 2003. - Yeah, it feels very 2005. - I don't think, I think wearing pink, wearing a pink shirt I don't think is a problem. for any high school kid anymore. - Yeah, also is 20, he's 21? No. - Oh, he's 21. He's, yeah, like he's-. - That's right, I forgot. - And his cash flow is cut off? Like who is-.

- He's an adult who can do what he wants. - He's an adult whose mom is taking him shirts. and not giving him money. - Maybe that's her like g rated way at giving him. the like the revenge back, 'cause she like didn't wanna give him a disgusting shirt, but she was like, I'll make you feel girly. Like I don't like it's so... - Haha, you're a girl now. - This is so good. - So that he's 21. I forgot I don't know why. the way they were talking, it was like, oh yeah, I guess. Sure. But no, what? - i Love that they-. - The way they're talking like JV soccer varsity.

- Me too. - He's talking like it sounds. like they're in highs school. - I know they're listening all of it. JV this varsity this. - Yeah okay, wait. - I love this family, I wanna hang out. - It's confusing. Oh, okay, I was confused. In high school, he was doing all that soccer stuff. and now he has a scholarship to a college. I just like that, It's like, ha... We took all your clothes away and cut off your cash flow. He is like, all right, I'm gonna go to the bar. (all laughing). Alright, you guys are weird. - All right, I'm gonna take my credit card. and go get a shot of whiskey at the bar. - Anyways. Okay, moving on.

That was a very fun first one. - That's good. - Good. - That's just, yeah. - Classic dad. - We kinda got like three movies out of it. - That was an episode of "Modern Family.". - Yeah. - That's just some good clean family fun. - Yeah. - It's an episode of "King of Queens" or something, yeah. - This episode of Red Stories is sponsored by Rocket Money. Rocket Money has helped me consolidate all my checkings. and savings into one big financial mural. that I can stare at all day every day. Like right now, you may think I'm holding this iPad. and reading Reddit stories, but I'm actually looking at all. my bills piling up and seeing what I can kick outta my life.

That's efficiency. Rocket Money is a personal finance app. that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills. so you can grow your savings. I'm constantly losing track of all my subscriptions. and when I can or can't cancel them. Also, I can set budgets and goals for myself using the app. and I can check on current transactions. and refunds all in one place. For the longest time, I had subscriptions. I'd completely forgotten about, and with Rocket Money I was able. to cancel them with just a few taps. And over the years, I've saved a lot of money.

off of not having any subscriptions I've forgotten about. It's been great. Let Rocket Money help you reach your financial goals faster. Join at rocketmoney.com/pitReddit. That's rocketmoney.com/pitReddit. Rocketmoney.com/pitReddit. And now back to the show. Oh bills. Our next story comes from, am I the asshole? This was posted in February of this year. Am I the for not inviting my cousin. to hang out anymore. after she kept making jokes about my life choices?

Okay. This could go a lot of places. So I, a 22-year-old woman have a cousin, I'll call her Mary, 23-year-old woman. And we used to be genuinely really close growing up like. our family see each other almost every weekend. We went to the same school for a while. and there was a point where she was honestly. my closest friend out of everyone I knew. We told each other everything. But over the past year or so, things just started feeling different. Hard to explain at first. Like nothing I could really put my finger on. just a vibe I was getting. So a bit of background.

I finished college earlier this year. and started working a full-time job. Nothing crazy, just a normal office job. But it was a big deal for me personally. because I worked really hard to get there. Mary on the other hand, is still figuring out. what she wants to do. and like I genuinely mean it. when I say I have zero judgment about that. Life isn't a race. and everyone figures things out at their own pace. I never once made her feel bad about it, or at least I really tried not to. But somewhere along the way. she started making these comments, little things at first that I brushed off. as just her sense of humor. because she is always been kind of a sarcastic person.

And I used to find it funny, stuff like, must be nice to already have your life together. whenever I mentioned anything work related. or some of us don't have it easy, like you, if I talked about weekend plans, she started calling me corporate girl as like a nickname, which sounds harmless, but the way she said it was always a little sharp. Like there was always just a tiny edge underneath it. that I couldn't quite explain. to anyone without sounding oversensitive. And it wasn't just once in a while, it became kind of a pattern.

If I mentioned being exhausted. after a long week, she'd say something like, try being unemployed and stressed. Must be rough having a paycheck though. - Mm. - If I talked. about saving up for a trip or something I wanted to buy, she'd go, of course you can afford it. with this little laugh. If I brought up anything about work at all, even just casually in conversation, there was almost always a comment waiting. on the other side of it. At first, I genuinely just laughed it off every single time. because I did not want to be the person. who can't take a joke. I kept telling myself she didn't mean anything by it.

And I was probably just reading into things. But then it started happening in front of other people, family dinners, group hangouts, even once. in front of some people we had just met that night. And something about having it happen. in front of others made it feel worse somehow, like I could feel myself getting quieter. every time we were in a group together. because I never knew when the next comment was coming. and I didn't want to have to laugh it off again. in front of everyone. I started kind of dreading hanging out with her, which made me sad because this is someone I genuinely love. and used to look forward to seeing.

Then a few weeks ago we made plans. to grab coffee, just the two of us. And within like the first 20 minutes she made a comment. about how I've changed since I started working. And then I'm too busy for real people now. And I don't know if it was just because I was already tired. or because it had been building for so long, but something about that one just hit different. So I said something, I kept my voice calm. I wasn't trying to start a fight or make it dramatic. I just told her honestly that the jokes had been piling up. and they were starting to feel genuinely hurtful. and I'd really appreciate it if she could ease up on them. She did not take it well.

She got defensive almost immediately. and told me I was being way too sensitive. and acting like I was better than her. She said she was just teasing. and that I was making a big deal out of nothing. The conversation got a little awkward after that. and we kind of just moved on, but it felt unresolved. After that I just stopped reaching out to make plans. I still reply to her texts when she messages me. I don't ignore her or anything, but I haven't been the one to suggest getting together. or initiate anything like I used to. Well apparently that did not go unnoticed. My aunt called my mom recently. and said, Mary is upset. that she feels like I've suddenly gone cold on her.

and she doesn't understand why I'm being distant. Which like, I get that it probably does feel. that way from her side, but also she kind of never acknowledged. what I said at the coffee thing. Now there's a bit of a divide in the family. Some people think I should just brush it off, keep the peace. She was just joking around. Others actually understand where I'm coming from. and think I had every right. to say something and pull back a little. And I really don't want this. to turn into some massive family drama. because I do care about Mary. and I miss the friendship we used to have. But I also don't want to go back.

to feeling uncomfortable every single time we hang out. and biting my tongue every time she makes a dig. So am I the asshole for slowly pulling back. after she kept making these comments, even after I told her how I felt. - That is so heartbreaking. - What a tough place to be. - Yeah. - It's so hard to like, yeah, just like obviously like hear the progression. of like the first couple times of being like, ah, and then it just getting worse. and worse and not knowing what to do. And then when you finally say something about it. to be just told that you're like overreacting.

Or like not hurt. - So exhausting. - To answer ops question at the end, I don't think you're an asshole for pulling back. after you've communicated your boundaries. - Yeah. Correct. - I think it gets into scary, it gets into like debatable territory when you pull back. without communication. - Sure. - But I think you did, op did what they were supposed to do. in that like they said what they needed. - Yeah, yeah. - They gave that person a chance. and then that person kept crossing those boundaries. - Yeah, I think she's handled, I don't know. how I would really handle it differently, it's really sad to like look at this,

especially now being in my thirties where you look at like, you're 22 and 23, right? And what's tough about your twenties is like yeah, you're all trying to figure your life out. And the paces at the time when you're 22 and 23, it feels astronomical. - It's so true. - You're successful. - So true. - And it's like you're both gonna be 30 one day. and it's, you're gonna be like, wow, I can't believe my twenties, I didn't find a job until I was 25. - Yeah. - 26. - And you found a job at 23. and now it doesn't matter. - Yep. - Yeah. - Or like I found a job and I got fired.

and my late twenties were crazy, and then at the end I found something. - Yeah. - Your twenties. are all over the place. and your thirties are all over the place. - Yeah, yeah. - Like as an actor, I think I can really relate to this. because like, I remember being a teenager, early twenties where someone would like book a movie. - Yeah, yeah. - And I'm like, and I haven't booked anything in three years. and I (beep) suck. and you can't help but feel resentful. But then a few years pass. and then that person who booked a movie. hasn't worked in a couple years and you're working. - Yeah, yeah. - And you start to realize like. oh, there's no such thing as like,

I'm better than you, you're better than me. - Yeah, yeah. - It's like we're all on this rollercoaster. - Well said, I really relate to this. And like in ways that like my twenties was that, it was like very hard. I had a lot of really good friends. and like my roommates, we like all, were just so close. and supported each other so much. But I think sometimes you can, like, you can feel. so insecure about how you're doing in your day to day. that then it somehow starts attacking you from the inside. And then you get mad at people for having things.

that you want and that, and you did nothing to get that right. You know what I mean? That makes me mad. It just makes me mad that life hasn't given that to me yet. So I'm, and then I think sometimes you're in such denial. about it 'cause you love your friends. that then you just start like attacking them. in little ways. Just because like honestly, I would at, I would always think about how like. I'm a double Libra. and like my want for fairness sometimes strangles me. because I'm like, it's just not fair. because you have that money, 'cause you grew up with that money and I'm working. and like, just trying to be like,

well it's different for some people. And like, I would like say stuff I remember. and then I had a friend that did this to me. a lot every time I came home. and I would like buy new clothes. She'd always like, oh, bought some stuff. You bought clothes. Like, she would always make me feel weird for spending money. and I didn't even have like, money to spend, but it was just like, it was a bad habit. - Yeah. - And she would call it out. and she would kind of be like, oh, I'm work. She had like more jobs than I did. And I just remember it was always. like a really small comparison game.

and like a fairness thing. - Yeah. - Being like, well you have extra time. 'cause you have this or whatever. And like, just saying that out loud, not to bring someone down, but to make you feel better. and in the end it never makes you feel better. - Makes you feel worse. - Yeah. - I can relate in feeling the resentment. and the like obsessing over like, wow, that person's life is, they have everything I want. - Yeah. - And like, at least like, oh, they're working a job they want-. - That's human, yeah. - Truly, like in my early twenties, like I was like, I had been single up until I was like in my early twenties, almost mid twenties.

and like I was very jealous of people. for relationships and stuff. - Yeah. - And I was just like, (beep), like, it's not me, but there's nothing more freeing than letting. like recognizing that resentment. - Yeah. - And like letting it go. - Or seeing that that resentment is getting. in between you and your friend. - Yeah, and also probably getting in between you. and your actual goals and happiness in life. - And it's stuff, 'cause there is so much like societal expectation of like, oh, you're, you finished high school, you gotta go to college, you finish college, you gotta get a job, and it's like so hard, especially like your early twenties.

There's so much going on upstairs nowadays, man. Like, it's like hard. Your brain is developing and it is hard. and it's stressful. And so like, I totally can like, empathize with like seeing someone who in your mind. you're like, they have it all together, but then you end up taking that out in a way, like in a negative way on your friend or something, and then not being able to like reconcile. and being like, I am sorry. - For sure. - Realize that that's really hard. - When you're feeling less than somebody else, for some reason always feels like. because your pain hurts sometimes.

Like, I'm trying to go back to when I would feel this way. and I would make little digs. and it was because I was hurting. - Yeah, totally. - And it was. because I didn't wanna hurt alone. - Yeah. - And I wanted someone to like. understand how I felt. And it's not that I never think I genuinely wanted. to hurt somebody else. I just wanted to go like, well, I'm hurting. So, and I and I-. - You don't wanna be left behind. - Exactly, and like, instead of just saying like, who I actually feel a little insecure. and like actually opening up then getting like-. - That feels like that your head says that's defeat.

- Yeah. - Right, like it's like, oh, if I admit it, then I am a loser, but it's actually, no, it's actually, it kind of acknowledges like, no, you're not, like you're just feeling this way. The reality of the situation's very different. - And it's like every, I feel like every person that is, you know, over the age of 30. or everyone is like, yeah, I found this thing, you know, my passion in life when I was 45, I found like my career when I was, you know, in my late thirties. Like there is no, everybody's timeline is different, but it's, it's really hard to see that when you are,

you know, young, the same age as someone. who you really care about. and probably like look up to in a way seeing them like, you know, succeed or do something. that you want to do. - Were they the same age or was it young? - They're pretty much the same age, I think they're 22 and 23. - So yeah, that's also, it's hard when you're like doing it together. - Yeah, and you're like, oh, and now I'm alone. Don't leave me here. - Yeah. - But I also feel for op, what a tough place to be in where it's like, oh, this person that I love resents me. for something I have no control over.

- Like, you don't wanna feel guilty for succeeding. or doing the things that you want to do, like making, you know, strides in your life. Like they're on a different timeline. They're on a different path. and it, you, it's really unfair to be made. to feel guilty for that. - Yeah, and like, I'm not one to usually gun for like, oh, cut someone out. or move gets like, move out of someone's life, but you don't have much choice when it's like, oh, this person wants me to be less. - Yeah. - Yeah.

- That is their whole desire is. for me to make myself smaller. What option do you have now? - I mean, a lot, I think almost all of my female friendships are, or a lot of my female friendships are people. who are struggling 'cause they thought safety is. making themselves smaller. - Yeah. - In environments, like, and that, it's unfortunate, because I do think OP should distance themselves. and I don't know if I would've had that ability to know that. or say that like five years ago.

- And I mean, once you have that conversation and try. and bring it up and they're still not willing to like, acknowledge that or accept it, then at that point it's like, yeah, you've done all you can do to like, try and help them understand. And it's up to them at that point to figure out. whatever's going on inside themselves. and release that insecurity or jealousy. or whatever it is and move on. Yeah, I mean, I'm also not like, generally speaking, not someone who's very quick. to like, oh, you gotta cut 'em off. But I think some distance away from someone like that.

in that situation is necessary. - Because I don't think this is gonna get better. - Yeah. - If she tried to talk to her. and it was met with that I'm like, this resentment's only gonna build. Her resentment is based on her own success. Right, it's like the only way this has a release is. if her friend gets a job that she feels is equal to hers. It's like, all right, like hope that happens. But even then it's like, is this the rest of our lives? - And you don't realize it at the time, but that could fundamentally like really affect. the way you walk into rooms. - Yeah.

- When you are worried about other people. - Yeah. - And that is coming. from personal experience. It's just hard, it's hard. - And I'm not surprised that. so many people in her family are saying like, oh, just brush it off. Just deal with it. Make yourself small. - Yeah. - Yeah. The verdict was not the asshole. Comments, not the asshole. She wasn't joking. She was taking little digs at you out of insecurity. and then calling you sensitive. when you finally said something, you didn't even blow up. You just pulled back to protect your peace. If she actually cared about the friendship, she would've apologized and adjusted instead of running. to the family like you wronged her. She did go and tell the whole family afterwards,

which is a betrayal, I think Op said, the point is, she never apologizes. She feels that's the best part about her. that she never backs down. Ugh. Someone said not the asshole. Those were not harmless jokes. They were repeated digs rooted in insecurity. The pattern, the timing, and especially doing it in front. of other people shows it wasn't just teasing, it was undermining you. You did the right thing by addressing it calmly. and giving her a chance to correct it. Her response wasn't to reflect or apologize, but to dismiss your feelings and call you sensitive.

That's the real issue. Pulling back is not punishment, it is protecting your peace. This is a natural consequence of their behavior. You're still replying and being civil. You're just no longer investing in a dynamic. that makes you feel small. If she wants the closeness back, she needs to acknowledge. how her behavior affected you. Op said, I am not sure that things will be the same. even after apologizing now. Wow, lastly, someone said, yes, she sounds jealous. I hope she comes to her senses soon. Takes what you said to heart. and changes how she acts with you. Not the asshole, if asked again,

tell your aunt to ask her daughter, you told her why at coffee. Op said, my mom told her that, but my aunt is defending her daughter. that she was just joking. Yeah, I, we have an update. - Okay. - Right, and I don't have much faith in it. I think this is gonna get worse. - Yeah. - I think. all the signs are there. That's gonna get worse. Okay. The next day. So this took a turn, I absolutely did not see coming. - Oh. - Oh so yesterday, a few hours. after my original post, I got a call from Mary.

and she was furious, like immediately yelling. the second I picked up. She went off about how I portrayed her wrong on Reddit. and how everyone is blaming her. and that so many people have read it. and now she looks terrible. I was honestly just sitting there confused. because like my post got some comments, but it wasn't exactly what she was saying. The comments were pretty measured. Some people agreed with me, some said to talk it out, nothing crazy. But she kept going. She started listing off all these specific things. I apparently said in the post, except, here's the thing, I didn't say half of what she was claiming. She was talking about details.

that straight up weren't in my post at all. Different scenarios, things I never mentioned, stuff that didn't even happen. That's when it clicked. She wasn't talking about my post. She was either talking about a completely different post. she found, or I don't even know, I tried to tell her that, but she wasn't hearing it. She hung up on me. Then apparently she went crying to her mom, my aunt, about how I publicly humiliated her on the internet. My aunt called my mom. My mom was confused because she'd actually read my post. I shared it to her after I got one such comment,

which felt funny and it was pretty tame. Then another cousin got involved trying to mediate. and actually went looking for the post Mary was describing. He couldn't find anything matching what she claimed. So then there was this whole family group chat thing. happening that I wasn't even in. but heard about later where people were trying to figure out. what was going on. And then, and this is the part that honestly made me laugh, Mary apparently let it slip in front of our other aunt. that she just did it to get a reaction out of me. The whole viral Reddit post thing, either she made it up entirely. or found some random post that vaguely sounded similar.

and decided to pretend was about her to what, make me feel guilty, start drama, get attention? I genuinely have no idea. The family group chat apparently went silent after that. Or maybe she found my original post. and just started exaggerating things. My mom texted me later like, so your cousin is something else. And I just had to laugh because. what else can you even do at that point? The funniest part, my actual post is fine. Barely got any traction just sitting there. minding its business while Mary created. an entire fictional drama around it. I don't even know what to do with this information.

Part of me feels vindicated. because this is exactly the kind of behavior. I was talking about in my original post. But another part of me just feels sad. because this is so much more unhinged than I expected. I haven't talked to her since, honestly, I don't know if I even want to anymore. This reads like she found the post. and then exaggerated the hell out of it. - We gotta make sure Mary doesn't listen. to Smosh reads Reddit stories. - Yeah. - Yeah. - It is why I can't go on Reddit, man. If I went on Reddit. and saw like, you know, found like a post.

or like one of my friends being like my, I have a friend who like works on. a very popular YouTube channel and I was like, ugh. Like that would be cr that would be... Actually, that would be really funny. Maybe I should start going. - I mean, I was gonna say like, 'cause you know, being doing this for 10 years, there's plenty of times where I've gone on. and read just conversations. with people like talking about me. No, like, oh yeah, I mean all the time. Right. - Actually, you know, you're so right. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, I know what you mean. - And so like, like not horribly negatively, but just like in ways where I'm like, oh,

I almost feel like I'm listening in on a conversation. I shouldn't be hearing, it's weird. - Always in the back of my head. wanted to write a Reddit story so bizarre, and see if somehow it gets on the show. - We'd probably clock it. (all laughing). - Probably too many spelling errors. - I also think the way that the cousin. exaggerated the story is. how she's exaggerating her entire dynamic with op. - Yeah.

- In her head all the time. - I think that's well said. - That's kinda how resentment works, is it like builds up to a fictional place. inside your own head. - God, it sucks so bad. - It really does suck. - It's heartbreaking too to like have someone. that you're that close to it, it sounds like, and are just like best friends with. and then truly not be able to do anything. And you just have to let them figure their stuff out. - I'm not like standing up for Mary, but I will say sometimes the pain. and like insecurity gets so strong that you go to extents. to get attention and love. She's trying to get OP to say sorry in such a dramatic way,

because she wants love and attention. in such a dark place that she's in. - Right. - That now she's lying. and she's like making shit up. - Yeah. and here's the situation. I mean, look, if Mary happens to watch this, I would say to her, I'd be like, you're gonna be so much happier. Like, you yourself will be happier. if you let this resentment go, and find like, apologize and want the best.

for the people that you love in your life. And I think, I believe that can really happen. She's young. I think people do go through these phases in life sometimes. and I think it's possible to learn these lessons. - Yeah. - But if she doesn't, she's gonna blink, and she's gonna be 40 and and miserable. - I was just gonna say like life right now, especially in the world we're living in is too hard. and too short to make anybody around you,

especially the people you love, make any of their goodness. a threat to you. It's just too dark, yeah. Like you're gonna blink and life's just gonna be done. - Yeah. - And it's just like, what? When a good thing happens to you, it happened to all of us. because life's hard, and we should just enjoy it, you know what I mean? - And I would certainly say too, to a unemployed 22-year-old, like, sorry that you ended up in like. one of the (beep) worst times to try to get a job and-. - It's like I can't imagine.

- You got (beep) over by like a million other people. than your cousin. - Yeah. - Be mad at them. Be mad at the system. - Yeah. - Like you, it is not your fault. that you're in the place you're in... - Do not take it out on the people who are there for you. - That's good point yeah. - You're gonna fuck yourself over even more. - It feels like OP did try to get Mary. to like let down those boundaries, let down that animosity. - Yeah, yeah. - It feels like. it just didn't work. - I think there are a lot of people that would've just been. like, you know, had that kind of pattern of behavior.

and seen it and just not said anything and been like, and just slowly distance themselves. and not explained it. And I think that, you know, for her to be like, yeah, this is what's going on. This is like how I've been feeling. And I really respect that, you know? - Yeah. - Yeah. - Able to do that. - And I just, it's just like, it sucks, 'cause it's like there is nothing better. than truly genuinely wanting the best. for the people around you right? And really wanting that. And it's hard when you're in a down place. But I would also say to Mary is like, there will come a time, I would bet money on it.

where OP is in a worse spot than her for whatever ways... - Whatever it is, yeah. - And in those times, you're like, I believe OP would still want the best for Mary. And you're like, the dynamic is gonna change over time. But it's great that when you have people that in your life. that you know that no matter the circumstances, you want the best for each other. and you're there for each other. - And even if you get, if you feel weird, I think just acknowledging it. and Going, Hey, it's been a dark month for me.

- Totally. - I wish I could like, but I still wanna support you. You know what I mean, and just saying it out loud, and being like, I don't, instead of just digs. - Yeah, I think that's something I think us here. at Smosh are very good about that. About it being like, hey, I'm feeling this feeling. - Yeah. - And acknowledging like, hey, this is an irrational feeling that I'm feeling. I'm letting you know I'm feeling this. - I'm saying that. - I'm not acting on it. I'm recognizing it, but I'm also communicating, I'm feeling this. - Because once you acknowledge it, then it's like, whoa, I got it out. - Yeah, yeah. - But if you hide it, then you're like, that's cool.

You went shopping today, I wish I could have. - And it's completely normal feelings. Like I literally in the last month have seen things. and been like damn. I wish I was doing something like that. And it's like, and it's normal. But then also it's, you feel so much better when you see someone doing something. and you're like, dude, that's so awesome for them. Like I feel so much more enriched. when I'm just happy for people. But it's a very human thing, like everyone goes through it, and it's just finding it out, like, you know, figuring out the way to deal with it. that isn't bringing someone down. - Should we kiss?

- Alright. Our next story comes from, am I the asshole? This is post in February of 2023. - Whoa. Am I the asshole for yelling at my girlfriend. due to her camera roll? - Da, da, da, da, da. - I know that every situation is different, but I feel like any, any story that starts off, am I the asshole for yelling at my girlfriend? - Like yeah. - I just like, I don't think there's ever been a situation where I'm like, yeah, that was, it was justified. to just yell at your partner.

- Yeah but... - Well, let's hear him out tr I'll hear him out. - Let's hear him out. - Hear him out. - Hold on. I'll hear him out. - There's gotta be some atrocious shit. in those camera rolls. - Yeah. - Me, 23-year-old man. and my girlfriend, 21-year-old woman, have been together. for four months now. She's great. Beautiful, crazy intelligent, and has the best personality. Genuinely my dream girl. Except for one issue. Her camera roll. For background she dated a guy for four years in high school. and the first half of college, she broke up with him last year. and has dated other people since then,

leading up to me. She never really talks about him. unless telling a past story about her friend group, which he was part of until he's suddenly up and left. According to her, the reason they broke up is she realized. they were on two different levels of maturity. When I mean, she's intelligent, I mean, she's well known around campus. and every professor adores her. and we go to a big 12 university. She also got life threateningly sick. and while he was worried for her, she knew he wouldn't be responsible enough. to take care of her in the future.

Progressive heart disease. They ended on good terms, but don't talk anymore. because he's kind of an introverted guy according to her. The part I get upset about is. every time she opens her camera roll. to show me a past picture, she scrolls past photos or videos of him and her. I've brought this up to her before and she always laughs. and says it's because she's too lazy to go. through 30,000 photos. She hasn't deleted pictures since 2015. These photos and videos of him. and her aren't romantic, their high school shenanigans, and usually involve her other friends. But I still can't help but feel jealous.

Today she showed me a photo of her friends in 2018. and told me a funny story. He's in the photo, I said, "You have a lot of pictures with him" in an annoyed tone. And she said, well, yeah. He grew up with me and my friends. We were kids together, it's like a look back into my childhood. I told her I didn't like those pictures. and she offered to remove them and put them on a drive. I told her that wasn't enough. She told me they were precious memories. she shared with her friends. and she wasn't going to delete. just because he was in a relationship. I kind of raised my voice.

and told her she should go back to him. if the memories were precious. - Kind. - She got up and said, "I don't want to go back to him, but I also don't wanna be with someone. who is emotionally insecure, I have enough to deal with," and then left. I've debated on texting her and apologizing. Am I the asshole? Buddy, I think you've already lost her. (Angela laughing). - I think maybe. - You talked about how smart and intelligent. and all this stuff about her, it sounds like she is, it sounds like she has no tolerance.

- Not looking Op, OP it's not looking... - Op. - It's not looking good. - It's not looking very good. - Yeah. - This is something this whole kind of conundrum, we'll call it, of deleting pictures... - Yeah. - And your ex. - Interesting one. It's so, and it feels like such a case by case thing. Like I can understand both sides of it, but in a situation like this where it's like someone. that she went to high school with, was like a part of a friend group and someone who, you know, she ended on good terms with and like, as he said,

they're not romantic pictures. Like I think it's very unreasonable to be like, I want you to delete those memories fully from your, like, I think it's very, her being like, I'll take 'em off my phone and just put 'em on a drive. Like I think that's very mature to be like, you won't have to see them if I'm showing you something, but yeah, I think asking her. to just fully delete those things is very unfair. - It is four months in. - It's also this problem I think is. gonna get bigger and bigger. Like, this is like, kind of like an old fashioned thing.

about, like, you, you still have stuff of your ex, like from the early two thousands. that now just like, even the idea of having 30,000 photos, that's like now we take them more, and we post them more. And this is only gonna get like a bigger thing. We're just gonna have bigger data logs of stuff. Like, and it's just, it's just gonna be hard, that's a lot of photos, and it's also, I keep thinking about it, 'cause sometimes you guys have the, on the iPhone they have the featured photos. You'll turn to the left and like, and you'll be like- - Get jump scared.

- Be punched by a picture of you. and your ex like on a date. And you're like, whoa, I didn't click on that, and it's just, you like scrolling to the left. and I've heard people talk about that and it's a feature, I think there's gonna be some kind of app or something, or you're gonna be able to call Steve Jobs. May you rest in peace and go delete all the pictures. - Get out the Ouija board. - Yeah, if these been like, do all the shit they're doing, they're gonna figure out a way. But it is a lot of work. And there's also so much more to this. It's just that he's threatened it sounds.

- Yeah, yeah. - And it's control too. - But it is an interesting new issue. - Yeah, yeah. - Right. Of like, oh, your Instagram, all your social handles, and all the photos on your phone. How you go about that is very complicated. But at the end of the day too, it's like, it's a matter of trust. It's like, what, what are you asking for here? - Yeah. - And him being like, well why don't you go back to him? It's just kinda like, all right man, you blew it, yeah, you're blowing it. - Why don't you go back to him? - Yeah, It's like, 'cause this is also photos. Like it's her whole entire high school experience.

- Yeah. - Like to delete a bunch. of memories from high school. It's also, I know the problem is they're like only 22, 23. But I'm like, it was high school, like, I don't know. - It's also just like kind of so immature. to like get upset when anyone has exes at all. - It's like, yeah. - Yeah. - That was a thing. - Like, hey, they existed. - Yeah. - And it's like- - Sorry? - It's like your life is so much bigger than like, you know, the person that you're dating,

it's like this person is like, this is the person that you're with, but your life was so much more than that at that time. And it's like those pictures. and your ex can be like, it's like, it might not be about the ex. It might be about like, oh, this is a trip that we took together. And I like really remember like, you know, going out of the country for the first time, things like that where its like... - It's all like a beautiful turtle. Don't make me delete the turtle. - Yeah, It's like you're, you're asking them to delete. so much more than just like, oh, this person in their life. - I think it goes back to. what we were talking about earlier is like, yeah, he's talking about feeling jealous and stuff.

It's like you can talk to your girlfriend about that. You can just be like, oh, like I-. - That's so true. - I feel insecure and stuff like, you know, like, because your ex like, I know he was part of your life. for so long and stuff. And she'd probably be like, you have nothing to worry about. - That's so true. There's like such something so human. that's like, I feel this kind of way, but I'm gonna make it about something else. - Yeah. - Really hard. because saying that I'm just jealous, threatened, or insecure is gonna be so much worse. than just hiding behind these photos. - And it's not gonna end there. Like, she could delete all the photos.

and something else is gonna come up. that's gonna jog up his jealousy and feeling of insecure. because insecurities is just there. So the verdict was obviously. Comments. You're the asshole, she is right. You're emotionally insecure. Someone said you're the asshole and deeply insecure, immature and controlling. Your girlfriend isn't obligated to erase. years of photos from before you met. because of your crippling insecurity. Grow up. You're the asshole. She showed you a group shot that happened. to have her ex in it. Asking her not to show you those pictures. because they make you jealous is fair. but expecting her to scrub four years worth.

of pictures when you've known her. for four months is a stretch. Update. - Update. - Do you think he fixes this. or do you think he keeps going down the rabbit hole? - I think he doubled down. - Really? I wanna believe that he got better. - I wanna believe that too. - I wanna believe that he fixed it. - Okay, let's see. Update the next day. - These are fresh updates outta the oven fresh. - I texted her this morning. and I apologized for crossing a line. She said while she accepted the apology,

the relationship wouldn't be continuing any further. She said a lack of self-awareness. and emotional maturity is not something. she can overlook when dating someone. So I guess I'm single now. Update number two from this year. - And how long ago is the other one? - 2023. This is three years later. - Whoa. Wait okay! - Oh god. - Okay. - What? What? - Wait. Don't. That's not fair, you're reading it before us. You can read it to us. - I didn't help...

- Just read it. Read it, read it. - Hi all. This is actually my post. Mind you, this is three years later. So surprise. First of all, it was fake. Sorry, I know that sucks. I'm actually a woman. And that post was made during my last year. as a journalism undergraduate. It was part of a capstone project where we determined. how easily it is to mislead people on the internet. and to induce public outrage. and how that influences far right and far left media pushing. under the moderation of our professor.

we each concocted stories or social media profiles. to try and stir up controversy online. Thanks to the original post. safe to say I got an A, I also graduated with honors. and with a special distinction for my thesis. The girlfriend was vaguely based on myself, except I have a kidney transplant and not a heart condition, and I exaggerated how well known I was on campus. and my looks and intelligence for sympathy of course, and who doesn't play up themselves in a fictional world. I've played D&D since then, I've been-. - Okay! - Since then, I've been a fairly successful journalist.

I've worked for both NPR and the Washington Post. I recently left my career behind though. and am now in law school studying international law. I can't believe this post is making rounds again. And I debated keeping the story as is, but too many of you all were DMing me the story. For future reference, some of you are far too gullible. Don't believe everything you read on the internet. That's how we got into this crazy situation. we're in here in the US. - Well, OP, he just reads it and I believe it. Okay, so OP, I'm not, I didn't know! - It's my job to believe it.

- He reads it. Okay, blame him. - Blame him. Blame him. Blame the producer. Don't blame us, we're on the couch. - Honestly, if I read that online, I'd probably be like, some journalist probably wrote this as a study. Wait, this is so sick. - Pretty awesome. It's also, yeah, it's true. Like every story we read on Reddit, I'm like yeah. I mean it's, it's an anonymous story. I take them mostly as hypotheticals. - This is sick as hell though. - Pretty good. - Wait, I'm obsessed. Can we wait someone send her this. Send OP this, comment OP on the video.

- But it is very easy to lie online. It's important to remember. - God, that was fun as hell. - Yeah. - I feel like I just in a cold plunge. (people laughing). An internet cold plunge where you believed everything, you're like, wait, actually no everything's fake. - I think at this point I'm not hit too hard by. 'cause I'm just like, yeah, I probably, a lot of 'em are. - No, sure, I just, I just love being like, hello I'm a journalist. - I'm John Quiñones, this is "What Would You Do?". - The novelty of coming back like years later. and being like, hey, by the way, this is fake. - It is also a little old to be like,

like I know we deal with what is on the internet being fake. or real constantly. So it isn't like a you're right things can be fake, yeah. Because there's so much of it in our day to day. Even like the news. - That's not that big of a surprise. - It's just the way she did it. - And she wrote this before ai (beep). - Yeah. - Took it. to a whole new level. - Yeah. - I also feel like it's a pretty mild story, so I'm like, yeah, I don't have, this is such a real scenario.

It's not like you wrote something that I'm like, I can't believe that happened. I'm like, your boyfriend was jealous that you had photos. of your ex in your phone. - That's almost why I'm more surprised. I was like, this is one of the most believable like stories, just like real stories. - I think we could throw a penny. and it would land on a jealous boyfriend. of a girl's phone camera roll. - Yeah, I'm kinda like, I guess a part of me. is also a little bit like, what was your, like what was your argument in this? In that like, oh this is dangerous. that I persuade people into thinking. that boyfriends can be jealous? I'm like...

I'm like, and it's like, oh actually, but so that story was fake, mind you guys are never jealous. - Exactly, you're so right, like if she made us believe something. that we don't normally can get behind easily. - Which does happen on the internet. and that is a very real thing, I think the thesis is true in. that we should doubt everything we see. on the internet nowadays. - But how about, you know, a fictional story. that's causing us to look inside of ourselves. and confront the issues that we have.

in our own insecurities. - That sounds like storytelling. - I think I read these in that kind of thing. - Me too, yeah. - Right, you know, 'cause I was devastated. when I found out Percy Jackson wasn't real. - Yeah. - Oh my gosh. - That was really (beep). - When I found out- - You took my pen in school. Why isn't it a sword? - But I believed when I found out. the "Hunger Games" wasn't real, I read that, I was like, can you believe what they're doing? - Oh my God. When am I gonna have to go when am I gonna have to go? - I have to volunteer. - When I found out Shizz University wasn't a thing,

I mean, my god. - Can I say though, there's an added layer to this too, and I think it's true for the internet of like, it is important to doubt everything I say. that hosting this show, right? Like be entertained by the internet, but do not take life advice. because you might go, you might go to Reddit and write a story asking. for advice about like your relationship or something. and keep in mind that. you might be getting marriage advice from a 12-year-old. - Yeah. - It's like so true. - Like you just do not know. who's commenting.

You don't know who's on the side. - Who's that 12-year-old? We need her on the show. - Like, just don't dunno what the (beep) is, like, because it's anonymous right? - Okay. This is what I was gonna say. What goes on in your guys' brain when you're reading these? Do you picture, like are you picturing the people visually? - Yeah, I picture a lot. - I picture 'em as Pixar characters, like super soft. - Whoa. - Kind of like the dad, I was picturing him like quintessential. like the dad in "Inside Out.". - Wow. - That's like, I'm not like really thinking in realism a lot with these. - Sure.

- Because it's just kind of bonkers. - Yeah, I don't think I'm picturing people. I feel like maybe in my head I'm like, well now, now you're making me think. - I know. Think about how you listen. - I know, I don't know. - Just think about that. - You know? And it's funny. This is interesting. And now that you made me think the first story. that we read about the dad. - What did you think he looked like? - You know, not actually about what the dad looked like, but it's weird that my head, when I imagined them, like going up to the house, it was my house from my childhood. I was like picturing, I was like when I had to.

picture like suburban family-. - You went to your house. - In the house, I like my was like, I went to my house from my childhood. - There you go. - I don't know. what that means. - Brains are crazy. - Brains are crazy. - Brains are crazy. When I found out some people do not think in images. and like can't think in images, I was blown away by that. - Yeah. - See, anytime I hear something like that, I'm like, what do you mean? Because I can't-. - Cannot form images in their head. - See, but like, I don't know if I can form images. in my head because I don't know what that means to you. - Ready? - You close your eyes. Can you see a red apple in front of you?

Like you like am I seeing like. as if there's a TV screen here and there's an apple? - Whatever, there's you, you can picture a red apple. - Lemme other one that we might cut, boobs. - Yeah, picture boobs. - You see it? - Uh, uh! - I can only describe boobs in my head. I can only see the word boobs. - I can only see one pair of boobs. - Our final story. Mysterious vibrating in my bedroom. - Been there. - Okay. It's not gonna suck itself.

(people laughing). - This was posted on RBI Reddit bureau of investigation, a subreddit where people use the power of the internet. to solve real world problems. - Now, okay, you peaked my interest. - What's in my ass? I don't know. - I was investigating the male G-spot. - That's crazy, you guys. - It was really dark in here. and I don't know what I put up my ass.

- You've been reading Reddit all day. and you ended your day with that one? (people laughing). - All right. - Man... I'm not going crazy, but there's a vibrating in my room that I hear. from time to time and it's making me paranoid. I live alone. No one else lives with me but my dog, the buzz I hear sporadically sounds. exactly like my iPhone. Just a quick short vibration, about a half a second. It's not my iPhone. as I hear it when I'm actively using my phone. and it's not my phone, it's not regular,

it doesn't happen in intervals. It's completely random. Sometimes I hear it often. Sometimes days go by. It's too quiet to hear when I'm watching TV. Almost always when there's no other sound. Sometimes it sounds like it's coming from under my bed. Sometimes it sounds like it's coming from the ceiling. I can't for the life of me figure out what it is. I live pretty basic, I have a light mounted on the ceiling, carbon monoxide detector and an iPhone charger in my room. That's all the electric things in my room. Could it be coming from inside the drywall? Plumbing, maybe. I'm not crazy, this is a real sound, but it happens so infrequently I can't pinpoint it at all.

Okay. What do we think it is vibrating? Just some something. and it's kind of different parts of the room... - I have in my apartment, like heard buzzing. and I thought it was a phantom, like me thinking I got texts before. and I, but like I have upstairs neighbors, and like, I don't know, like I've always been like, oh it sounded like a buzz. Like there's so much shit going on, it's the wifi, I don't (beep) know. - I've been going through this actually. in the last couple weeks. because I've been hearing this sound.

that's like a little bleep sound and I dunno what it was. And it's one of those things that like I just can't be asked. to get up off the couch. and like try and figure out what it is. But then I asked Raven. and I was like, "Is that your computer?". And she's like, oh I've heard that, and she's like, I thought it was your computer. And I'm like, if you're sitting in your office. and it's not coming from your computer, I don't know where it's coming from. and it's like kind of been driving me crazy. but also like in a way that I'm like, I don't... - God. - What's going on? - We're all so cooked.

- We're all here. - We're hearing sounds. and we don't know what's going on. - We don't know what the (beep) it is. (all laughing). - We dunno what it's man and it's like... - We don't know what's going. - (beep) (beep). - For me to figure it out man. - Okay, so someone commented, you say you live alone, but are you in a single family home or in an apartment? - Yeah. - My old apartment. had some pretty thick walls. but the floor and ceilings were not, I could hear and possibly feel my upstairs. and downstairs neighbor's phones vibrate. - Yeah. - Mostly upstairs. because I think it was on a table, so the vibration amplified through my ceiling.

You don't live in an apartment? I don't know. OP said one bedroom house. - Whoa. - That makes me think. like it's ventilation or plumbing or like pipes. - Yeah. - A rat. - That's the only thing. Or a rat. Like a big fat rat with an iPhone. - Rat, I feel like a rat getting so many emails. - Like you know how like your AC unit like cycles it like. starts up like turns off where like, you know, it rustles on. and there's like a little vibrating as it's, I dunno. - Also, I don't know, maybe one of my devices is listening. - Maybe it's the government. - I, you know,

everything's listening everything. - Yeah, I mean that's kind of true. - You know what I mean? - I'm not gonna doubt that. - I can go, Hey Alexa, anybody's gonna, anybody? - Keep going? Well a lot of listeners just got pissed off. - Yeah. Hey Google, it's not gonna suck itself. - (beep). - Sorry. - Someone said, oh god, this would bother me so much. Maybe the co detector, maybe a fan. or some electrical buzz coming from the light? - Fan. - Maybe something with the water heater. or wifi modem router. What other rooms are butted up with the bedroom?

Start taking note of the times of day. you hear it most often. Obviously I would guess it's mostly at night. when you're in bed as that's the quietest time. you're in your room. But see if there are other times you notice it. Note what other things are or aren't happening in the house. That should narrow it down at least a little. Well OP said that's a good idea to keep a log, see if the times match up. or if there's a pattern, will do that. Someone said just to add a sense of panic. let's mention that there's phantom vibration syndrome. - That's what I was thinking, like we're all buzzing all the time. Like who (beep) knows.

- Op said, oh I've had phantom phone ring for years. I've always had that. This isn't physical, it's auditory. I hear it buzzing. Sorry. So phantom vibration syndrome is a real thing. according to Wikipedia. Phantom vibration syndrome. or phantom ringing syndrome is the perception. that one's mobile phone is vibrating. or ringing when it's not. PVS is technically a hallucination. because your brain is perceiving something. that isn't actually happening. So is that because like how... - That happens to me all the time. - Because that's how like. what we are seeing and and hearing. and everything is not actually what's in front of us. It's what our brain is interpreting.

So it makes sense that if emotion. or something your brain is so used to phone vibration. that it's like that's what that is. So it makes you feel that. - And I'm used to that sound, I'm used to that feel. I'm like used to it on my couch and like feeling it. - And especially when I'm expecting calls. and it's during the day, I'm like always being like, I'm like and I check it and nothing changed. - Okay. - But I get texts. so don't worry guys, I like, I get a lot of text. - Like I'm getting calls and texts, I swear, like sometimes. - I get like a lot - Always getting. - And it's like, that's probably why I have it.

because it's like I'm just always getting text, I'm like surely I'm getting a text right now, 'cause I'm always-. - Just like hit up. - Update. - Okay. - 1.5 years later. - Took him one and a half years to figure it out. Damn! - Any last guesses? - Alien? - Could be. Could be. - Alien? - You look, I'll hop on the alien train. - I'll go with mm. I'm gonna go with something some weirds in the walls, a drone? - Drone. - Drone.

Okay, I'm about to read it. - Yeah, that's usually how that goes, yeah. - Well you last guesses. - Okay. Thank you, thank you. - Posted about a strange buzzing in my house over a year ago. and I never was able to figure out what it was. I heard it so infrequently. and irregularly that it was almost impossible. to figure out what it was. Every time I'd hear it, I'd immediately stop. what I was doing and go real silent waiting. with bated breath, hoping it would buzz again. Almost like a cruel joke. It would only buzz after I gave up waiting. and went back to whatever it was I was doing. Even up to last week, I'd still hear it. sometimes multiple times a day,

sometimes weeks would go by without hearing it. I'm pretty sure I figured it out. and it's comically stupid what it was. So I was sleeping in the middle of the night like 3:00 AM. and I woke up and was in a semi sleep days kind of drifting. The world was real quiet and it was a deep silence. and I heard the buzz, but for the first time it almost immediately repeated. and kept repeating in frequency. Almost like a rhythm, I was 100% sure. it was my phone ringing on vibrate. So I started groping around the bed to find my phone. because the buzzing sounded exactly like my phone buzzing.

every two seconds for about half a second. Once I found my phone, the buzzing continued. but I couldn't quite place where it was coming from. This is gonna sound crazy and I'm amazed this is the source. But eventually my alertness. and physical movements woke my dog up. and the buzzing immediately ceased with a grunt. The buzzing was my stupid shepherd's exhales. Like his every exhale or possible inhale. I'm not sure it was buzzing, exactly emulating a cell phone buzz. - This happened to me like two days ago. - That's crazy. - This happened to me, I can't believe I didn't think of it.

This happened to me two days ago. I was sitting, I was laying on the couch. and my dog, I like had my arm down. and he laid, Napkin had like laid his head. and his neck was resting on my arm. And then I kept feeling this buzzing. and I was like, why is I thought my phone was buzzing, but then it was on the armchair. And I was like, what? And then I realized it was like his neck in the exhale. - It was a journalist. - It's showing us that internet is-. - It was actually actually John Quiñones. - Napkin goes, I've been working for the Globe. - I've actually been seeing- - I work at the Globe. - You cannot trust anything you hear vibrating. - Yeah. - That's crazy. That's crazy. - It is happening to you. - Oh my god.

- I'm decently confident that this is the same buzzing. that I've been hearing for years. And also the reason that I've been unable to source it, because every time I hear it. I'll get super alert and tense, which immediately wakes up my dog. as he's super attuned to my behavior. and his breath buzzing stops. Then when I relax and give up the search, he goes back to sleep as the situation is over, that's when I hear it again, and he again wakes up to see what's got me agitated. I also only ever hear it during moments of calm. when I'm lounging, never when I'm active. and moving about the house. So this would make sense. that it's only ever when my boy is sleeping.

I'm pretty satisfied with this answer. And when I do hear it again, I'll be on the lookout. to see if it's the dog nose next time as well. - It happening. That's crazy. But it was like, I felt the vibration on my arm was. like, I don't, I would've heard it knew. So I felt it and I was like, what was that? And I was like, oh it's, that's so funny. That's incredible. - Because then every time you do. you move like your doggy is gonna stop was like. - What's going on? - Yeah. - Let's get it. - What a prank. - Wow. - He was like we're looking for that buzz again. What's that buzz we're looking for? - He's like, the dogs are just like, what the (beep)?

- Yeah, yeah. - The dog's going-. - Wait, did you hear that, dude? - Yeah, the dog, like what was that goes, I heard it too. Where was it? - I heard that dude. - Honestly, I bet it's the (beep) cops. - Yeah, dude. Something in the walls, man. You gotta bust open the walls. Somethings in the walls. - My cat's purrs are like too obvious I feel like, but with cats, cats make you less anxious. because they're unlike dogs, which I feel like are by your side a lot more, cats are just all over the (beep) place all the time. So you'll hear weird noises. and you're just like, that's probably my cat getting up.

to shenanigans. - You're just used to weird noises. - Like here's something, the only thing. that wakes me up is I'm, I'm like, I'll hear something. I'll be like, they're on the (beep) counters. and I'll be like, you bastards! It's like, like I hear you, get off. They'll just hear them all over place. - They on the (beep) counters. - They on the (beep) counters again. And like the funniest was, there was one time, this was like a few, we were living in a different apartment. and we had built these like shelves so. that the cats could get up to above the kitchen. - Yes I love those, yes. - And Bones was unable to hop up high enough.

But one of the nights he tried. and I, we wake up to like a crash, we hear like a boom, and then I run out. and I just see Bones in the middle of the floor, just like his tail puff just kinda like... And I was like, did you fall, hit the trash can and hit the ground? (all laughing). Because he was just so embarrassed. Just kinda like... - He is like, no dude, that was someone else. - He was like that he was, that wasn't was... - Like, dude, there's a weird buzzing sound. It sounds like a cat's falling.

- I don't know what happened. - What's the threshold? I sometimes I think about like, what's the threshold of weird noise. you could hear before you could be like, is my place haunted? Because I'll watch like ghost hunting shows. and they'll just be like in there silently. and they'll hear like the littlest noise. They'll be like, oh my God. I'm like, I feel like I'm always hearing noises. - I hear so much shit and it's fine. - Whatever. - Make a lot of noise. It's why okay, this, 'cause people know I'm a bit of a skeptic, right? - Yeah, yeah. - Now I'm not saying. I don't believe in those things, it's just that so many people I'm like, if you want to believe in the things.

that's what you're gonna hear, 'cause we're talking about how our brains perceive things. So if you're telling yourself it's a ghost, I'm like, you're more likely to like make. that pattern make sense to you. - Yeah, yep, you ready for this? I'm gonna wrap it all up in a bow. - Okay, yes. - That same thing. - And so like I'm thinking that... - Killed, killed, killed. - That was good. - Wow, It was the dog all along. - It was the dog all along, this time you can blame it on the dog.

- And now you can. - Anyways, thank you both for being here, for all these updates. - You are the best man guys. - Thank bro. - You're the best. - You're the (beep) best. - I bring, I love you guys. - This is awesome. - Love the show. - Time for Bed. - I love. - All right, alright, well guys, it's time for bed. I know for some of you it's 11:30 in the morning. but it's time for bed. Sorry, I make the rules. Thank you Trevor and Angela. And thank you all for watching. and hey, we'll see you next week.

Update. We're having another show next week. - Update another episode comes out. Love you. - Bye! (upbeat music).