The Millions of Poor Americans at the Mercy of the Shutdown

From The New York Times, I'm Rachel. Abrams and this is The Daily. >> [music]. >> You get benefits on the first, yeah? Yeah. And what happened today? Um, they. just didn't load. Says that they will arrive, but they. will be late. The Trump administration has agreed to. restore some of the funding for the food. program known as SNAP. But there's still uncertainty. >> [music]. >> about how much money will come through. and when. What would that normally look.

like today? Um, it would be like 780. Is there an account balance? Um, I have 12 cents. Tens of millions of Americans, one in. [music] eight, rely on SNAP. Without. federal assistance, many people do not. know how they will provide for. themselves or their families. I adopted. my grandson, he's two. And it's terrifying thinking I can't. feed him. Now that that's been frozen, I literally. have nothing in the house. It's It's not.

everybody's fault that Congress can't. make a decision on a bill. So they shouldn't punish the low-income. family, the needy people, because that's what we rely on. >> [music]. >> Today, we hear from people in one of the. communities most reliant on food aid. >> [music]. >> And from my colleague Tony Rom about the. ongoing fight over SNAP as the. government enters its second month of a. shutdown. >> [music]. >> It's Tuesday, November 4th.

Are we getting going? It looks like we're going to start. rolling now. Red truck is one. One. Last Friday, Daily producers Olivia. Nat and Anna Foley went to Kermit, West. Virginia, a rural town of about 300. people. How about paying me? Apples and. meat, same thing. One per family, up to. two families per car.

There was a mobile food pantry set up. outside a Baptist church. Volunteers. loaded items including eggs, potatoes, plums, and cucumbers into people's cars. >> Got bread here for you, honey. Honey, that's good. You're Thank you. West Virginia is one. of the top recipients of SNAP benefits. in the country. About 16% of West Virginians get food. assistance through SNAP. And even with. the extra help, a lot of people rely on. food pantries, especially at the end of. the month, and especially this month.

when there hasn't been much clarity. about whether benefits were coming or. not. Hi there. My name's Olivia. I'm with The New York. Times and I was. >> Olivia and Anna spoke to people. about what they were planning to do. next. some kind of news or something? >> I am, yeah. >> Okay. Do you all want to talk? >> [laughter]. >> you're right. Mac. My name's Anna. Um, so could you start by telling me your. name and, you know, where you're from, how long you've lived here, a little bit. about yourself? My name's Roy Messer.

and I'm from Kermit, West Virginia. My. name's Teresa Hodge. I live here on. Stone Coal. Right down the hall. My name. is Breanna Lockhart. I was a stay-at-home mom for a while, but just recently went back to work. because of the shutdown that's going on. >> [music]. >> And um, what brings you guys out here. today? [music]. Well, right now times are rough. I mean, they took the food stamps, so. you got to do what you got to do, feed.

your family. I'm picking up for me and I. brought my cousin with me so she can. Get meat. Get [snorts] some meat. Yeah, that's. what they said. It was supposed to be. meat and some food. >> I've seen the list and they have turkey. and eggs. >> That'll work. At least I'll be able to. have something for Thanksgiving. What can a box of food do? Like what is. the impact for your family? Well, that's. going to be able to effectively feed my. family for an extra week. You know, we're going to be in a struggle to make. sure that it's either going to be food. or bills because even though my wife.

works full-time, we still depend on SNAP. benefits to help get us through buying. the extra [music] meat and stuff like. that. Since there'll be no stamps, this. food bank will be the only. food I have to go in [music] my house. How much money do you receive if you. don't mind me asking? SNAP, 136. I think it's like 292. I get a whole $63. How far does $63 go for you? Two bags.

And you might get a box of crackers, maybe. You know, even with your food stamps, usually. about two weeks before the. month comes back up, you're scheming. tight. You run to food banks trying to. get help, you know. Just plain and. simple. Can you describe like what a. dinner would look like like with your. SNAP benefits and then if you can. imagine, you know, if you don't have the. SNAP benefits, what a dinner looks like. in that situation, [music] too? Oh, with the SNAP benefits, we don't. have a good Southern meal like fried.

chicken and green beans, mashed. potatoes, all the good stuff, rolls, all. that. But without, it's more like hot. dogs and. ramen noodles and stuff like that. And. that's just not healthy. It's really. not. When did you find out that you probably. weren't going to be receiving benefits. for November? >> About two weeks ago. When the government. got shut down, we kind of had an idea. that, you know, like if people aren't.

going to get paid their their salaries, then. government assistance is going to be the. last thing they're worried about. >> [music]. >> And, you know, when that realization. kind of struck you, how did that make. you feel? It made me feel less important to my. lawmakers than what I used to feel. It's. like I served our country in the Navy. and it's like I feel like my family as. veterans doubly gets looked [music] down. upon because we just get cast aside.

We're angry. We're angry. Because, you know, we do. count. To be honest, I have a lot of hatred. Like and Trump was one of those that I. was all for, but now I feel like he's. more about the money and helping the. rich and like not caring about the. people that really do need help. The Democrats down there is. they don't need to be getting their. payday, but they're all rich people, so. it don't, you know, it don't hurt. Their. kids and grandkids ain't going to go.

hungry. You know what I mean? >> [music]. >> What are your plans for making ends meet. this month? Hunting season's coming in, so that helps out a lot. You can't really depend on the. government really [music] for nothing, so you got to. Eat more squirrel. And deer. >> [laughter]. >> If I had children, I'm going to tell you. something. I'm going to feed them. babies. Whatever it takes to do it, I'm. going to feed them. You think people might get really. desperate? Yeah. They are now.

>> [music]. >> We're going to be against each other. over something as simple as a loaf of. bread. before it's over. There's already people that have to. decide between food and their medicine. Yeah. Have you ever had to make a choice like. that? Couple of times. Couple of times. And it weren't for this food bank it. were about two months ago. If it weren't.

for this food bank, me and my little. grandson would have starved for about 10. days. We eat mashed potatoes and macaroni for. four days out of this food bank. And I. wouldn't have nothing to eat with that. little boy if I hadn't them. And most of the time I didn't need it. all. cuz I'd make sure he had something. I'm so sorry. >> And yes, it's very upsetting. You can. understand that, right? And [music] I think it's a sad state of. affairs when poor people that are not.

able to work anymore, and I worked, believe me, my whole life, can't even. get a way to eat. >> [music]. [music]. >> Coming up, my colleague Tony Rom. explains the standoff in Washington. that's delayed [music] SNAP funding. We'll be right back.

So Tony, we just heard from people that. our producers interviewed at a food. pantry in West Virginia and we heard a. lot of confusion and a lot of worry. Could you explain what is going on with. SNAP funding right now? SNAP is in a very difficult place and. the concerns that you're hearing out of. West Virginia are concerns that we're.

hearing nationally as this shutdown now. lapses almost into its sixth week. SNAP. is a program that serves about 42. million people across the country and. even though it's a permanent fixture in. law, lawmakers have to put money into. that program every year. But because the. shutdown has gone on so long, SNAP has. exhausted its normal budget. And so. that's left this program at a bit of a. crossroads. You've been following some legal. challenges to the administration's. position that it wouldn't or couldn't.

release any SNAP funding. What is the. status of those challenges? We've seen a number of cities and states. and nonprofits file lawsuits against the. Trump administration over the way that. it has handled SNAP during the. government shutdown. And this all. stemmed from a decision that the. administration made just a few weeks. ago. Initially, USDA said it was going. to tap a special set of emergency funds. to pay SNAP benefits if the shutdown. dragged into November. This is a pot of.

money that was roughly about $5 or so as. of late October. That's supposed to be. used in instances where SNAP doesn't. have enough to cover benefits for. everybody. And that's a lot, but still. not enough to hit the roughly $8. or so that it needs every month to keep. those benefits flowing. But sort of. abruptly, the administration said it. wasn't going to use this money after. all. And that this huge fiscal financial. cliff that we were seeing for the.

program as we entered November. And so. cities and states and religious groups. and others filed lawsuits against the. administration essentially to force the. release of funds. In [snorts] both. cases, federal judges have found serious. issues with the way that the Trump. administration has handled the SNAP. program. But only one of those courts, at least so far, has ordered the. administration to spend that money. And. told the administration that it had. until Monday to essentially say how it.

was going to do so. We finally got that. information from the administration. And. the short of it is that the Trump. administration is just going to tap only. the small set of emergency funds that it. has for SNAP and not some of the other. money it has laying around across. government. And as a result of that, it's going to make partial payments to. people, but those partial payments may. be perhaps half of what families are. expecting to see in the month of. November. And it's not even clear when. that money might reach the millions of.

people who depend on SNAP. So while in. some ways it was a bit of a victory for. people who subscribe to this program, it's a little unclear if it's actually. going to provide the kind of relief that. these families truly need. Is there any precedent for any of this? Has anything like this happened before? No. No, we've we haven't seen anything. like this with the SNAP program. I mean, there are fights around federal safety. net programs all the time, but you know, both sides admitted while they were in. court that there had never really been.

anything like this. Mhm. So I can imagine that this is really. confusing to the 40 million people that. rely on this funding to feed themselves. or their families. Can you remind us who. are these folks? What does the money get. used for and how exactly does the. program work? So SNAP is the Supplemental Nutrition. Assistance Program and it's the largest. anti-hunger program that the federal. government offers. There are about 42. million or so people who receive. benefits under SNAP every single month,

which amounts to about one in eight. Americans. And these are people located. all over the country. They live in rural. and urban areas. They live in Democratic. and Republican-leaning communities. Many. of them are children. Some of them are. veterans. They're seniors. It's a pretty. wide swath of the population that relies. on this critical federal safety net. program. But there are some restrictions. to it. Generally speaking, to get on. SNAP, you have to make or earn an amount. of money near the poverty line. For.

people who qualify, the average benefit. per person is about $187. a month, which is critical to helping. these people buy groceries, but doesn't. go all the way in meeting all of their. nutrition needs. And so that's why SNAP. is part of this bigger picture of food. pantries and other services that help. address the issue of hunger here in the. United States. And in short, the way it. works is that the federal government. approves money for SNAP and eventually. that money makes its way to states and.

on to benefit cards that millions of. Americans use. How did SNAP end up in the crosshairs of. the administration to begin with? SNAP has been in the crosshairs of. Republicans for some time now. It even. predates this administration because. there's a belief among Republicans that. many of the people who receive those. benefits don't actually need them or. don't deserve them. And so we've seen a. number of instances in which Republicans. have led efforts to restrict who can be.

part of SNAP and the kinds of benefits. that people can receive. And we saw this. most recently in the context of the. debate around the president's tax. package where one of the ways. Republicans offset the massive costs of. that bill was to cut SNAP, to impose new. work requirements on recipients, which. helped save Washington some money, but. also created a situation in which. millions of people may lose access to. benefits as a result. And so in many.

ways, what we're seeing right now is. that play out on a much larger scale. Because while President Trump has been. willing to move around various pots of. money within the budget during the. shutdown to ease some of its impacts, he's largely done that for programs that. he personally cares about or those that. may be essential to his political. agenda. But in others like SNAP, where. Republicans have long sought to cut, this administration has not been as. generous and hasn't been as willing to. move money around. And indeed, that's.

why this administration is only. providing partial payments. It's because. a court has told them to. >> [snorts]. >> Basically, what you're saying is that. during the shutdown, the administration. has found ways, sometimes questionable, sometimes temporary, but nevertheless. has found ways to pay for other things. it needs to fund, like the military for. example, other federal employees. So. this feels a little bit more deliberate. and I just sort of wonder what purpose. withholding SNAP serves politically.

In some ways, this is about political. retribution. If you rewind the clock. back a few weeks when President Trump. was asked about the shutdown and how he. was going to handle it, he said that he. was going to go after quote Democrat. programs. And President Trump at the. time didn't really explain what he. meant. He didn't identify anything. specific. But what we have seen since. the president made that threat is a very. deliberate effort across the. administration to cut funding streams. that they associate with members of the.

political opposition. And even President. Trump sort of acknowledged this just a. few days ago when he said that the SNAP. program was one that largely benefited. Democrats, that most of the people on. the program were Democratic voters. We. know that that is not indeed the case. But throughout all of this has just been. this very clear effort to go after areas. that Democrats like in a bid to pressure. them into coming to the negotiating. table. How does this fit into sort of the.

larger agenda of the Trump. administration vis-a-vis. cutting the government, shrinking the. government, cutting programs? Yeah, in many ways this fight, this. crisis around SNAP is just a microcosm. of everything that President Trump has. been trying to do with federal spending. since he returned to office. You know, on one hand, this is about. rethinking the size and the reach and. the role of government in Americans'.

lives. And you can see that in the. programs that the president has looked. to cut. That's cuts to federal health. and education and science and research. and other programs. And the reality that. his budget for the 2026 fiscal year, if. Congress were to adopt it, would set. domestic spending at its lowest level in. modern history. But beyond that, the. other really dynamic facet of all of. this is that President Trump and his top. budget advisor, Russell Vought, have. gone to great lengths to recalibrate the.

budget without the approval of Congress, which has that power of the purse under. the Constitution. They have closed. entire agencies and laid off droves of. workers and halted billions of dollars. in federal spending enacted by Congress. without getting lawmaker support. And so. the SNAP program just really sits in the. middle of all that because it shows the. ways in which the president wants to. rethink those federal safety net. programs and the cuts that he aspires to. make, but also the ways he's willing to.

use presidential power to achieve them. So now that the administration has said. that it will comply with the court order. and find a way to fund the SNAP program, at least partially, how quickly does. that mean that people who receive SNAP. benefits will actually see that money in. their accounts? Yeah, that's the big question and in. short, we just don't know yet because. the Trump administration previously told. the court that by providing partial. payments, it could take potentially. weeks or maybe in some cases months.

before the federal government and the. states could get these benefits out to. the millions of people who depend on. them. This could have been avoided. potentially if the government had chosen. to provide full payments and had tapped. other sources of money to backfill that. shortfall, but the Trump administration. opted not to do that. And as a result, millions of people still find themselves. facing the same uncertainty today that. they did a few days ago about when that. next SNAP payment is going to arrive.

Which makes me wonder, just to go back. to West Virginia for a minute, a state. that Trump won handily in the last. election, people are angry and people are. confused. They don't understand why. they're losing their benefits. And so it. sounds like the political calculation is. that this will ultimately benefit. Republicans more, especially in these. shutdown negotiations. But do you think. that that is correct? What is your. assessment of the political calculation. that's been done? Yeah, I think they bet that A, it will.

be the kind of thing that pressures. Democrats into negotiating. And B, that. absent that, the president can. accomplish what he proposed to do as. part of his 2026 budget even without. having Congress vote on it. Whether that translates into a victory. in the eyes of the American people. remains to be seen. I think there have. been times where people have blamed the. administration for the cuts across. government and the ways that that's. affected their daily lives. But there's. also been times where I think people.

just blame what's happening on just the. general mess of Washington. And the. result isn't that they see it as the. work of one party or another, but just. another chip away at their confidence in. the work of government. And so I think. that's in many ways one of the lasting. repercussions here. It's just another. instance where people look at Washington. and think this place isn't doing. anything for me and I can't count on it. for help when I'm in my greatest need.

>> [music]. >> And so in many ways it really just. distills how bad things have gotten here. in the nation's capital. And the real people who might be hurt in. the process when the two parties can't. talk to each other. >> [music]. >> Tony, thank you so much. Thanks for. having me. >> [music]. >> We'll be right back.

Here's what else you need to know today. Kimberly-Clark [music] will buy Kenvue, the maker of Tylenol, for $40 billion. A. signal that the consumer products giant. is betting that the painkiller can. weather a barrage of attacks from. President Trump and his administration. The president and others [music] have. made unproven claims that the use of. Tylenol and other acetaminophen products. during pregnancy [music]. can lead to autism. And.

President Trump weighed in on the race. for New York City mayor on the eve of. election day. >> [music]. >> In a social media post, he endorsed. former Governor Andrew Cuomo in his. uphill battle to defeat Assemblyman. Zoran Mondani, the Democratic nominee. >> [music]. >> And he vowed to limit federal funds. going to New York City if Mondani wins. Today's episode [music] was reported and. produced by Olivia Nat and Anna Foley. with help from Mooj Zaidi. It was edited by Patricia Willens with. help from Paige [music] Cowett and. fact-checked by Susan Lee.

Contains music by Marion Lozano and Dan. Powell and was engineered by Chris Wood. Special thanks [music] to David. Fahrenthold, Rachel Culbertson, and the. Facing Hunger Food Bank. >> [music]. [music]. >> That's it for the Daily. I'm Rachel.

Abrams. See you tomorrow.