What's The Best Ice Cream Sandwich?

What's the best snack brand Ice cream sandwich? Let's talk about that. [Funky Intro Music]. Good Mythical Summer. We're about to try ice cream sandwiches, but first, this. portion of today's episode is sponsored by AG 1, a daily drinkable scoop of vitamins, minerals, probiotics, and whole food source ingredients in one. AG 1 is one of the easiest things you can do. for your health every day. Not only does it fill nutrient gaps in your diet, it also.

assists immune health. When you eat as much as we do, it is hard to. maintain a healthy diet. But one scoop of AG 1 contains 75 plus vitamins, minerals, pre and probiotics, and superfoods to support. whole body health. I love a routine and drinking AG 1 every morning. makes you feel more energized and supports your gut health. Now is the best time to give AG 1 a try. Get started with AG 1 for less than $3 a day. When you subscribe, just head to the link in our.

description or scan the QR code. And look at everything you get when you subscribe. Using our link to order scores you $76 worth of free extras. Plus you get this fun morning person hat to get started. All we need is eight 12 ounces of water. Mm-hmm. You're doing the water and a scoop of AG 1. in our shakers. I'm the water guy. Oh, see, I'm pulling out my thing here from the--. I'll be the water and the shaker guy. You can be the scoop guy. I'm the scoop guy.

Here comes the scoop buddy. Boop, right there. And then all we gotta do, I'm gonna put it is. a little bit of a shake. You don't have to keep it in the box that it comes. in, but I do really like the punch when it comes in. You can shake with either hand or both, and. then you, you drink. It tastes good too. And these green drinks don't always taste good. This one tastes really good. You want the vitamin D and vitamin K too? I do. I'll take that with, alright. So join us in creating a healthy habit that's. actually easy to maintain. And thanks again to AG 1 for sponsoring this.

portion of today's episode. And welcome to the first day of what everyone. everywhere is calling GMM's Beat the Heat Week. Woo. They're all calling it that, every episode this. week we're gonna beat that heat of the hot, hot summer, the best way we know how. Frozen desserts, and not always in the way you expect. beginning today with ice cream sandwiches. But not just any old regular kinds of ice cream sandwiches. Because big brands such as Pop-Tarts have begun turning.

their iconic snacks into ice cream sandwiches, and. the public deserves to know if these frozen treats are. really as good as they sound, and which one is the best. That's where we come in. It's time for ice cream Sando, Sando Sando, the. 2025 Snack brand ice cream sandwich tournament. Okay, boys up first in the competition to be crowned. the Beat the Heat champion. We have the breakfast snack bracket with the frosted. strawberry Poptarts ice cream sandwich versus. the Eggo chocolate chip ice cream sandwich.

And before you taste, please say hello to our. tournament board controller today, the ice queen. Burrrrr. Ooh. Oh, it is so cold in here today. I feel practically c-cu-cubed. Hello, ice queen. Hello. Where is your land? Me. I come from the land of freeze. Uh, the land of freeze.

On the planet colds. In this, in the system of, oh, those icicles. That's a, I love the naming convention. Are you, are you dancing a little? This is just how my people move. Okay. I am very excited. To get to know you. Yes, yes. Uh, also to get to know these, because I didn't. know that they've, I didn't know they existed. Ice cream sandwiches have gone so far and that. is an actual Pop tart.

Is it? I mean, is it though? No, look at it. It's Pop Tart. If, if this doesn't have filling in it, then I got. a bad feeling about it. It's got filling in it. There's two miniature Pop-Tarts with i. with strawberry ice cream in the middle. Yeah. See, you can look at that. I mean. That's, that's wild. I don't even know what to say, man. WOWD. Sometimes we just encounter things on this show. Leave me speechless.

We are wowed. Um, very good. I'm not a huge Pop-Tart guy, but. I really appreciate this, uh, addition to. the culinary universe that we are exploring. They have strawberry, but they also have frosted. brown sugar, cinnamon, and frosted chocolate fudge. options, outta nowhere, all of these. Eggos doing it, they, they must have colluded. Oh, you think so? You know, for all of these brands to be making. the sandwiches and look how beautiful that is.

It's that collusion. It's competition, man. But for it to happen at the same time, they had. to note, they talk, they talk chocolatey chip. They also have buttery maple and blueberry. It's soft. This one tastes a little buttery and maple-y. But what I'll say about this. Because that's not an Eggo waffle. Nope. This is a ice cream sandwich material deserted, made to. look like an Eggo waffle. It's very good.

It's uncommonly and unexpectedly soft. But this is two Pop-Tarts. Yeah, it beats it. But I'm gonna enjoy another bite of this before we. send it to the ice cream sand-pit. Well, it's on your side. Do you think 'cause of you do the honors, a sand witch? Yeah. Has it? Have you ever encountered a sand witch? A sand witch? Yeah, I don't speak of my sister any longer. Oh, wow. She's on another planet, the desert planet.

Oh, I get it. Take that, you witch. Right on time. We are gonna head on over to the candy bracket where. we have the M&M's ice cream sandwich versus the. Reese's ice cream sandwich. Now you know the peanut butter boys are here, okay? And I wanna say this is like when you go to a talent. show and the person who's judging the talent show their.

daughter is in it, you know? And it doesn't seem fair, and I know you're thinking that. But you know what? We're gonna look at our daughter with, we, we we're. gonna despise our daughter. She has to overcome our despise in order for us to. let her go past this route. Right? Yep. Well, a lot of coaches do that when their kids. on the team, right? So this is pretty straightforward. Yeah. I'm already bored. What is the cookie?

It has nothing to do with it's just, it's just. well, you know, the kind of an M&M's cookie that you. get at like a. It is a common cookie to get a cookie like. this with M&M's on it. Like a sugary cookie. Yeah, it tastes good. I like to lick all the way around the rim of the ice cream. Oh,, I'm surprised, you like to do something with food that nobody. wants to watch. Yeah. Yeah. Well then it look away. We're shocked. Okay, now our daughter over here, she's got--.

A tan? Typ-typical. Ice cream sandwich, sandwich parts. Uh, I didn't mean to say parts, uh, but I did. Uh, and then we just have peanut butter ice cream. I mean, seems a little boring. Yeah, but it's good. Oh no, go deep. No, don't do your thing. You're missing the giant dollop of real peanut. butter in the middle. Leave me alone while I lick my daughter.

I was setting you up for that. I know. And you fell right into my sand trap. Oh, what, what is it? The peanut butter ice cream tastes good. Hmm. That's nice. Throw that away. Okay. Well, our daughter, I can't help it. She's great. So let's move her along. Ice queen. Move her along. Yeah. Re the, re the Reese.

We'll move her along. I just miss my family. Is your sister the sandwich an ice person as. well, who just lost her cool? Oh, if you had the time to know about my sister. We don't put that away. Yeah, we, yeah, we get it. Up next in our dessert snack bracket, we have the.

Oreo ice cream sandwich versus the Rice Krispies. treats ice cream sandwich. I mean the Oreo one. This is kind of expected, but also kind of intriguing. I think I've had something like this before that is. very Oreo like, and we've got cookies and cream, ice cream in the middle. That's a great choice. Yeah, the packaging is beautiful, beautiful, simplistic. I love it. I love it.

That's just such a good taste. Just a good taste. I like Oreo. Is this exactly an Oreo? I think it's fluffier. No, no, no. It's, it's not, it, it's, it would be way more crumbly. if it was a real Oreo. Yeah. It's got appliability to it. I apply it to many situations, including entertainment. But this is unexpectedly obvious to never. have seen it before. Yeah. What he said, look how thick, look how thick these.

Rice Krispy treats are. They're thin. Do they have to do it that thick? Are you, you're saying the lack of thickness? No, I'm saying they're thinner than a real ice, rice krispies treat. Right. But they're, that's the thickest sandwich piece that. we've encountered today, but still a lot, but still half. the size of a treat, but the exact same thickness as. the ice cream in the middle. I mean, that's interesting. We like the proportions, but we're a bit perplexed.

Hmm. What happened? The rice crispy treat is soggy. It's not crispy. Is it not real? Is it a different thing? I think, um, I think it, there's something else in it. It, it tastes exactly the same. It's the freezing of it. I think if you freeze a rice Krispy treat, this. is what happens to it. But it's not, there's no crunch at all, which is disappointing.

It's definitely not bad. I really wanted to like this. But it's not as special as this. Ice queen, did you wanna like this? Un crisp, crisp, medium, well, rare. Any kind of rice crisp. I'll have a crisp pivot. It sounds like you never had it. Yeah. And you're just trying to seem like you're. fitting in with humans. I love Rice Crisp. I love Ore-a-o. Yeah. Yeah. See, she's just trying to fit in. We love the Ore-a-o a lot more, so it's the one that's moving on.

Yep. Oreo moving on. Oreo moving on. And I hate to do it. Especially 'cause their box is pretty nice too. Not this nice look that, but oh gosh, they're. falling out of the pit, Rhett. Yeah. Not my fault. For round four we gave the OG ice cream sandwich. Brand chipwich a buy. But since this is all about snack based ice. cream sandwiches, this isn't just any old chipwich. It's the Girl Scouts thin mint chipwich. Oh gosh.

Against. The Frosted Strawberry Pop-Tarts ice cream sandwich. I am sorry. I'm very excited about this. This is my favorite ice cream flavor. It is. I mean, yeah, I have like three favorites. It's one of them. Oh. I just love the smell of it too. You see how it's bulging outta one side? It's kind of, you know. Not mine. Roiding out a little bit there. Um, mine's perfect. I think that's okay. Oh, good. But what do you think about the chocolate chips? Just stuck to the sides.

That's awesome. That's beautiful. Trendsetting and standard bearing. So it's not trendsetting, it was at one point? Yeah. Mm-hmm. What do you mean? 'cause it's standard bearing everything. Everything that's standard bearing was. at once trendsetting. But I don't think it could be both. I don't love mint ice cream. I do, but I can tell that the quality is there. So I'll give it that. No, we know these are special.

I love the way it stands up when you take it. out of the pack if you know what you're doing. Um, yep. That happens to me every morning. The, um... Two for two. How many groans can I get today? I'll bring my daughter into this again, If you don't stop groaning. She'll be back in a second. Um. Man, it's hard not to love that. I know.

It's totally different. I don't even like strawberry ice cream. Me neither. I'm sorry. This is like another daughter of mine and I'm. saying bye to her because Pop-Tarts is just too good. Yes. The fact that it's cold. I think prob probably some people actually. freeze their poptarts, which is a good idea. Okay. Poptarts moving on. Do you have any um. Ice, ice babies. You asking me if I have a child? Yes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's not, that's a sensitive subject on, on my planet.

You don't ask a woman if she's got a child. Oh, if she's a mother. That's a secret. Oh, okay. What, what, what's an appropriate question to. ask you on your planet? You could ask me what's the weather like and. which one do you prefer? Okay, so go ahead. What's the weather like and which one do you prefer? I prefer it when the big red balls outside and I'm bundled.

up in my big white coat. I don't really understand your planet. [Speaking made up language]. Move to the next. Now she's--. Hurry along fellas. She's moving us. I wanna make you do this. Oh, yes, you did it. Oh, it just so happens that we're wearing these. two new flavors of our Belvedere ice cream tees.

on this ice cream episode. Yeah. What are the chances? These are brand new. We got the cookies and cream, and we got the mint chip. Mm-hmm. Which is your favorite. I'm glad you're wearing it. Yeah. Uh, we also have a restock of our strawberry, vanilla, and chocolate variety. So scoop yours up at mythical.com, aight? Next up we have our round two winner, the Reese's. Ice Cream sandwiches, uh, versus our round three. winner, the Oreo ice cream.

What are the chances that you're in front of. cookies and cream with a cookies and cream shirt on? Hmm, a hundred percent man. Why, why did they skimp on their packaging and packaging? This is, this could be orange. A lot of them are beautiful. It could be orange. So even if, yeah, it doesn't even have to say Reese's. It could just be orange. Uh, I think I wanna start over here. These are both real solid, let just tell you. right now, like it, that was a little bit lazy. Uh, it was a big lazy, also, the, the, the thing.

on the outside could have been made to look like a. Reese's Cup, but they didn't. Whereas, Hmm. This looks with a little crown. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Like a little bit of a crown or something. Engineering. Engineering problems. Well, or just like the outline of it. This one. It looks beautiful, I gotta tell you. So tasty. It's so good. But if we're just looking at taste,

I don't know man. And that dollop of peanut butter in the middle. It's real strong. I'm, but I don't think it's better. I, I don't think our daughter is better than this. other someone's daughter. Yeah. I'm agreeing with you. You, you think the Oreo is better? I do because, I'm sorry. The peanut butter boys are losing it. And I'm not just being hard on you because. you're in the family. Right. And I, and I want to have high standards.

High expectations, but also a lot of support as a parent. You gotta have both of those. Icy. Moving on, girl. Did you call me icy? I thought we were friends by now. I also called you a girl. I, that was, felt a little risky. I'll tell you what, I kind of liked it. Oh, okay. I haven't had a friend in so long. Okay. Bestie. Bestie, but okay. But you don't have a baby yet either. Is that what going on here? You can't ask.

Nevermind enemy. Oh, you ruined it. Unfortunately, Reese's daughter, you going in. the sand pit eventually. I love that sound effect. For our final round, it's the round four winner. The Frosted Strawberry Pop-Tart ice cream sandwich. versus the round five winner, the Oreo ice cream. It all comes down to this. Now, let me note, I said it before, but I'll say it again.

These also come in Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon and. Frosted chocolate Fudge, which that the, the Frosted. chocolate fudge has chocolate ice cream on the inside. So I kind of feel like as good as this is, both of. these would be better in my opinion 'cause I'm not. much of a strawberry guy. Mm-hmm. But, and the strawberry is hitting real good. Yeah. So I'm kind of letting the strawberry represent. all three flavors. It's knocking it outta the park just like the beat. the heat trophy platform.

Look at this thing. We've got a baseball bat beating the heat, which is a, a sun or a fireball or something. Well, the sun is a fireball. We're going, we're gonna put the winner up here, boy. It's gonna be a glorious moment Ice queen. I cannot wait to crown the day. The way we were interacting with you in the last round. I guess we assumed there was no Ice King. I apologize if that was--. I'm a lesbian.

Okay, so is there another ice queen? No, I'm single. Oh. But I'm looking. This is tough, but not really. Because this is exactly what you'd expect. And they've nailed every aspect of it. It's perfection. It's very, very good. Maybe the best ice cream sandwich that I've had that. fits almost a traditional expectation, and then. this subverts and, and, uh, sets the standard.

It's 2025. We're looking to mix things up. Yeah. We have to award the, in the innovation here. So, so that means that we're gonna, we gotta. throw this away first. Yep. Because we want to give this this moment. Yeah. Yeah. And now go ahead and put it in its rightful place. Pop Tarts. Pop-eh. Sandwiches. Tartie. Yep. Poppy Tarties.

And put it out there. It's the best ice cream sandwich. It's the Beat the Heat Champion. Congratulations, Pop Tarts. Thanks for commenting and sharing this video. You know what time it is. Well, howdy fellas. My name's Sebastian and it is a beautiful day here in. Zion National Park in Utah. I'm just chilling at my yurt and it is time to. spin the Wheel of Mythicality. Is he putting that accent on? Probably not. Click the top link to watch us build our perfect.

summer day or a perfect day at summer camp. Got ya! At Good Mythical More. And to find out where the Wheel of Mythicality is going land. New flavors of Belvedere ice cream shop tee's. now available at mythical.com.