We Tried EVERY Cheerio

What's the best flavor of Cheerios? Let's talk about that. Good Mythical Morning. How many different kinds of Cheerios cereal do you think there are? I would. Wrong, there's 24. I didn't even get to guess. And do you know how many we're trying today? All of them. Wrong, all of them. It's time for Gut Check: Cheerios Edition.

Okay boys, today you'll be tasting all 24 flavors of Cheerios available in the US. to decide which is the best of the best. In case you need a palate cleanser, we've got a heart healthy liquid. solution AKA water in your mugs. Thank you. Your first category is classic Cheerios, starting with original cheerios. The original disappointment. How do you wanna do this? You want to stick your tongue in? Okay, it's what you did. I kind of did, um, a sucking, a sucking bite like the horses do.

Oh, that's gonna get messy. That's dry, boy. Oh man, I ain't no baby. That's a, that's a non cheerio, cheerio. Man, you get past that when you're three. You, you don't eat that after three. 18. Uh, 27. Multi-grain Cheerios. Oh. Now. The suck thing don't do, that you could choke and die like I almost did.

They got a, um, a flavor on that. Well, there's sugar on it. Yeah, there's sugar. So it's better than the first ones. 19. Not much better. Um, no, I'd say it's, I'd say it's 37. Frosted Cheerios. Uhhuh. Oh, what a naughty Cheerio. Hmm. Makes it tastes like something completely different. Have you had these? I don't think I have.

Hmm. Not bad, but. I give it a 58. I'm gonna give it a 50. It's just, I don't know. Hold on. Did you want those to be better? Honey Nut? No, it was the beginning of. Oh, oh. Honey Nut. I've been waiting for this. You were still talking. Oh yeah. Honey Nut Cheerios. Here we go. Classic. Okay, now we're.

Can this be beat? Now we're in, now we're in Cheerio Land. Honey, nut, sweetness. Man. Woo. Hmm. I'm gonna, I'm gonna leave a little room. I mean. I'm gonna give it a 93. That's, I mean, to jump from 50 to 93. There are six other slots. Unwarranted. There are other, there are still six slots above that. Um, it's very, very good, 82.

Classic. 82. That concludes the classic Cheerios category. Our next category is crunchy and protein Cheerios, starting with a Maple. Cinnamon Hearty Nut Medley Cheerios. What do you mean. When you say protein? You just mean like it's got others. When I say protein, you say. Eat it. Oh, um, no, there's like actual protein ones that you'll eat. There's a flake in it. So the crunch is from the flake. Even though the O already had a crunch.

Do we need other stuff? Do we need other stuff besides the O's? Yeah, man. Yeah, we gotta keep, we gotta keep trying other O's to make sure that the one. that we liked before is still better. No, do, do we need other shapes? I don't. Oh no. Believe in flakes in the O's. Oh, you're going to anti flake. Anti flakes. I'm a head and shoulders man. This was a little mapley. I do like that, 74. The flavor is not bad, but I'm really anti flake. 49. Cheerios Oat Crunch, Oats 'n' Honey.

Double oat, huh? Hmm. Hmm. I got it. I like it. Hmm? It needs milk so bad. Like these need milk so bad. I know. I really like this one. I'm gonna give it an 88. What do you like about it? I like the oat-y taste. It's still very sweet. I think there might still be like a honey-fied-ness in there.

I don't like the oat-y taste. 48. Cheerios Oat Crunch Chocolate. Oh, here we go. What? Hmm. Very crunchy. It almost Captain Crunch. I like this a lot too. 87. I think this is just your day, man. I like oats and I like chocolate. It's better than the last one.

60. Cheerios Oat Crunch Cinnamon. Hmm. I mean. I'm sorry, I'm making a mess. That's a strong cinnamon flavor. I'll clean it up. I'll clean it up. Y'all get me a dust buster, okay. I was going to say, I didn't think. Gimme a dust buster. We need to sit, if I want cinnamon in a cereal, I know where to go. And it ain't to the O. It's Cinnamon Toast Crunch. Well, you don't have to say it. Oh, I'm sorry, take it back, edit that out.

You know, it's, I like to leave a little intrigue in my commentary. Keep his intrigue alive. But that gives me pause. You think that's anywhere close to Cinnamon Toast Crunch? No, but it's, it's really crunchy. And it is really tasty. 51. 71. Cheerios Oat Crunch Almond. What? Oat and almond. Oh, and there's little almond pieces. Now. Uh uh.

What is that almond flavor? That is not flavored like almonds. Somebody land and explain it to me. I know what you're talking about, but it's it take, it reminds me of one of those cookies. Ugh. Um, I actually. Horrible. 74. I'm an almond lover. 74. Matter of what's your, what do do? The ta, the flavor. It had flavor. None of the rest of 'em have had anything. It has a fake, that's not the flavor of almonds. Yeah, but you knew it was.

No, you knew it was. 11. You knew what they were going for. 11. You know when your parents are trying to show you love and then. they doesn't come out quite right. Next one. I know that you were trying to love me. Next one, Stevie. Strawberry Cheerios Protein. Now that's a fake taste right there. That's a fake strawberry taste right there. We don't need this in our lives. And then the protein tastes horrible. Throw the rest of that away.

Oh God. Um. Oh. 2. I mean, I was gonna. What you, what were you gonna do? Just to, well, I'm gonna do an 11. Okay, good. Cookies and Crème Cheerios Protein. Protein. Everything doesn't need protein. Yeah. There's protein in milk. Didn't know that until recently, but there is, so just do that. Yeah. There the protein taste is just.

17. 17. Cinnamon Cheerios. Protein. Protein. You didn't have to do this. Cinnamon covers it up a little bit. Mm-hmm. 27. 31. That concludes the crunchy and protein category. Our next and final category is Fruity, Chocolatey, and Miscellaneous-y.

Bring it on. Is it about to get good? Bring it on. Starting with Fruity Cheerios. Just, just fruit. Oh, look at all the different colors. Pastel. Oh, hello, Fruit Loops. What? It's like fruit loops from a distance. Not as strong, not nearly as strong as Fruit Loops. I feel like I need fruit loops right now to disprove this man. Well, listen, I can tell you. Just because they're smaller O's, you think they're not as strong.

Oh yeah, the flavor's weaker. I like that you were looking around as if you were going to see Fruit Loops here. Well, you never know, there's so many surprises. The taste is good. Um. I like Fruit Loops, so I like these. And they're smaller. Sometimes a Fruit Loop is a little bit too big for my mouth. I have a small mouth. I get that. 59. 79. Very Berry Cheerios. Okay.

Wow. The, the scent of these is punchy. This tastes like another cereal. Franken Berry. Yeah, something like that. Uh, I don't like it as much as the Fruit Loops that we just had. I don't like. My cereal will taste like candy, and that's what's happening here. 22. 67. Frosted Lemon Cheerios. This is gonna be bad. Frosted lemon.

Not as bad as I thought. Hmm. It's like a lemon bar. It's like ingesting a cleaner. That'd be a good little ingredient on something. Most all lemon things are. And everyone ingests a little bit of cleaner naturally every day. And a credit card's worth of plastic every week apparently. I think that was disproven. Yeah. Um. But you perpetuated it, so that's okay. I'm in the... 17.

No, no. I like this one. 65. Chocolate Cheerios. Just chocolate. Because the other one was chocolate oat. This is way better than the oat chocolate. I like the other one way better. You do? What's a Cheerio made out of already? Oats, right? Wheat. Wheat. Wheat oat. I don't know. I like this because it's Cheerios plus chocolate.

80. I just stepped on those. I'm gonna give it a generous 69. Gonna need that dust buster. Chocolate Strawberry Cheerios. Oh, so it's a little bit of each? Uh oh. Nope. The chocolates and the strawberries that they used to make these are. totally separate from the other ones. They don't just combine the factory lines. You have an inside source. I am just trying to insult your intelligence. Well, previously you had strawberry protein.

Ah, so, yeah. So your, in your insult was just intelligence. That's right. Right. I'm so, I'm so, you're smart. Yeah. Um, I don't like that. I don't. The strawberry one. 42. 43. Strawberry Banana. Whoa. Cheerios. Do they have just banana? I hope not. Oh man. I almost, can you have, is there a banana coming? Mm-mm. Okay. Set those aside.

They would never do that on their own. A banana cereal. That's, that would be so good. So I'm just going to pick out. Banana peanut butter, maybe. Banana strawberry, not necessary. 39. The banana is so good. You love the bandana? Yeah. Why do you love the banana nana? Banana by itself would be a hundred. Strawberry is uh, like a 12. Now, you have some other banana combo flavors coming up.

You don't have straight banana, so I don't know what kind of calculations you're making. Just go with your gut. 44. There's a point to this. Banana Caramel Cheerios. What. They are, I mean. Is there a banana chocolate? This seems desperate. It's tough to stay in the moment when you think about banana chocolate coming, maybe. 15. This is better than banana strawberry.

This might be a 68. Apple Cinnamon Cheerios. Okay. An Apple Jack. It tastes like Apple Jacks. From a distance, but these are not as strong as Apple Jacks. Mm-hmm. And they're smaller. See? But the Fruit Loops, they're strong. I like this. I like this too. 60. 84. Not that much.

Cheerios Veggie Blends Apple Strawberry. Okay. What. I think they're trying to tell you that you're eating. vegetables in it and you can tell. Just so you feel good about just letting your babies just eat bags of these. Um, yeah. If you let it sit in your mouth too long, it just turns into fish food. 41. 30. Cheerios Veggie Blends Blueberry Banana.

Okay. Banana's back. It tastes like chocolate to me, but also candy. Banana mixed with blueberry. It tastes like chocolate. 15. Ah. It's not great. 27. Confetti Cheerios. Oh, they're shaped like a hearts. Oh.

Hmm. Tastes like a birthday cake. Hmm hmm. 51. 61. Okay. Pumpkin Spice Cheerios. Of course. Hmm. Where's the flavor? I'm looking here. Looking there. Pretty subtle.

I bet it would turn my milk orange, and you know what I mean by that? Okay, tell us. We don't. That the milk would be orange. Um, that wasn't great. 47. I'm talking about your joke. 47. 29. 47. That concludes the Fruity, Chocolatey, and. Miscellaneous-y Cheerios category. You've now tasted every flavor of Cheerio. It was that easy. Your scores will be tabulated.

We wrote a book for the kid in your life. Whether that kid is picky or silly, or a little bit of both, or none at. all, they're gonna like this book, Spaghetti Head and Chicken Fingers. Pre-order it now at MythicalBooks.com. Get it. We are about to give you your top four Cheerios to try again and. crown your favorite as the Superio. But first your collective least favorite was Strawberry Cheerios protein.

Yeah, of course. Your individual favorites both grabbed a spot in the top four. This go round. They are Honey Nut Cheerios. Cheerios Oat Crunch Chocolate. Oh yeah. Chocolate Cheerios. Oh yes, we get the pair. And Apple Cinnamon Cheerios. So we get to compare chocolate to chocolate. Okay, but Link. To determine which is best. We need to milk these. Of course, it's kind of my thing. Look at that. And the, the difference between these two chocolates is yes, they both are.

made out of oats, but the, the one that says oat on it has oat pieces, crunchy oat pieces, oat crunch. On the, on the actual O, it's an additional thing. Well, let's, let's go, let's do chocolate on chocolate and see which one's better. You like the oats better the first time. And now we get glorious milk. Oh, man, they needed milk so bad.

Note the crunch. Very crunchy. I like that. That's part of it. Let's go over here. Do the exact same thing, just a different bowl. Not only does it have the not have the crunch. It's different chocolate. It doesn't have as much chocolate. It's a different chocolate. This is chocolatey-er.

I think it's even a different chocolate. It's a stronger chocolate with a stronger crunch. They're so different, honestly. Can't tell you which one I like more at this point. I like the crunch of this one, but there's something about the traditional. That's gonna put it over the edge. The traditional, uh, taste. But you feel strongly about this one, so. It, well, and it makes the, the milk darker. Oh, it's certainly doing that.

All of that's a factor in aesthetically pleasing-ness. Okay. This one isn't outta the running. Right. Let's move to, to, uh, Apple Cinnamon. Apple jacks are a bit too much. Too big if you have a little mouth, is what you were thinking, right? This is just, this is the surprise for me.

I would get these. It, it absolutely tastes different and I would say more grounded than an Apple. Jack, but, but very tasty, very accurate. Apple Jack's too far out there for you. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Confusing philosophically, right? Yeah. I, uh, philosophically I'm confused. Right? Right. And, and we've saved what we have always believed to be the best for last.

The Honey Nut. It's the quintessential honey nut cereal. I mean, it's got the bee on it. It's just so good. Man, I, I want to take this and I wanna put it here. Do you wanna move that? No. And then you're, you're respecting the fact that with how much I've. pushed that this goes here, or there.

And then this goes there. I think we all know what's going on here. I think, I think there's, there's just nothing that tops it. Honey Nut, Cheerios. They should have stopped. Before they started. They should have stopped. They didn't need to do anything else. Boop boop. That's us checking out with more of those. Honey Nut Cheerios is the Superio. Okay, well, better late than ever.

At least we were ready for it this time. Thanks for commenting and sharing this video. You know what time it is. Hi, I'm Sarah. I'm Ash. I'm Kaya. And we're from Vancouver, BC. And for her 22nd birthday, we're playing Gut Check. And it's time to spend the Wheel of Mythicality. She's got a scoring chart. Happy birthday Ash. All right, brace yourselves for this Unfun Fact.

Tigers and zebras are both animals with stripes. Click the top link to watch us shop for groceries blindfolded in Good Mythical More. Pre-order our kids' books, Spaghetti Head and Chicken Fingers now at MythicalBooks.com.